Thielmann Anika, Viehmann Anja, Weltermann Birgitta M
Institute for General Medicine, University Hospital Essen, University of Duisburg-Essen, Hufelandstr. 55, 45147, Essen, Germany.
Trials. 2015 Jul 14;16:301. doi: 10.1186/s13063-015-0824-9.
Immunization programs are among the most effective public health strategies worldwide. Adequate vaccine storage is a prerequisite to assure the vaccines' effectiveness and safety. In a questionnaire survey among a random sample of German primary care physicians, we discovered vaccine storage deficits: 16% of physicians had experience with cold chain breaches either as an error or near error, 49 % did not keep a temperature log, and 21 % did not use a separate refrigerator for vaccine storage. In a recent feasibility study of 21 practice refrigerators, we showed that these were outside the target range 10.2% of the total time with some single refrigerators being outside the target range as much as 66.3% of the time. These cooling-chain deficits are consistent with the international medical literature, yet an effective, easy to disseminate, practice-centered intervention to improve storage conditions is lacking.
METHODS/DESIGN: This randomized intervention trial will be conducted in a random sample of primary care practices. Based on continuous temperature recordings over 7 days, all practices with readings outside the target range for vaccine storage (+2 °C to +8 °C) will be randomly allocated to a web-based education program or a waiting list control group. The practice physicians and their teams constitute the target population. Participants will be educated about best practices in vaccine storage and will receive a manual including storage checklists and templates for temperature documentation. In all practices, temperatures of the vaccine refrigerators will be monitored continuously using a data logger with a glycol probe as a surrogate for vaccine vial temperature. The effectiveness of the web-based education program will be determined after 6 months in terms of the proportion of refrigerators with vaccine vial temperatures within the target range (+2 °C to +8 °C) during 7-day temperature logging. Secondary outcome parameters include temperature monitoring, no critically low temperatures (≤ -0.5 °C), compliance with storage recommendations, knowledge of good vaccine storage conditions, and assignment of personnel as vaccine storage manager and backup.
Keep Cool will develop and evaluate a web-based education program to improve vaccine storage conditions in primary care and thereby ensure immunization safety and effectiveness.
DRKS00006561 (date of registration: 20 February 2015).
免疫规划是全球最有效的公共卫生策略之一。充足的疫苗储存是确保疫苗有效性和安全性的前提条件。在一项对德国初级保健医生的随机抽样问卷调查中,我们发现了疫苗储存方面的不足:16%的医生有过冷链违规经历,包括失误或接近失误的情况;49%的医生没有保存温度记录;21%的医生没有使用单独的冰箱储存疫苗。在最近一项对21台诊所冰箱的可行性研究中,我们发现这些冰箱在目标温度范围之外的时间占总时间的10.2%,有些单台冰箱在目标温度范围之外的时间高达66.3%。这些冷链缺陷与国际医学文献一致,但缺乏一种有效、易于推广且以实践为中心的干预措施来改善储存条件。
方法/设计:这项随机干预试验将在初级保健诊所的随机样本中进行。基于7天的连续温度记录,所有疫苗储存温度读数超出目标范围(+2°C至+8°C)的诊所将被随机分配到一个基于网络的教育项目组或一个等待名单对照组。诊所医生及其团队构成目标人群。参与者将接受关于疫苗储存最佳实践的教育,并将收到一本手册,其中包括储存检查表和温度记录模板。在所有诊所中,将使用带有乙二醇探头的数据记录器持续监测疫苗冰箱温度,以此作为疫苗瓶温度的替代指标。在7天温度记录期间,根据疫苗瓶温度在目标范围(+2°C至+8°C)内的冰箱比例,在6个月后确定基于网络的教育项目的有效性。次要结果参数包括温度监测、无极低温度(≤ -0.5°C)、遵守储存建议情况、对良好疫苗储存条件的了解以及指定人员担任疫苗储存管理员和备份人员。
“保持低温”(Keep Cool)项目将开发并评估一个基于网络的教育项目,以改善初级保健中的疫苗储存条件,从而确保免疫接种的安全性和有效性。
DRKS00006561(注册日期:2015年2月20日)