van Dam Loes C J, Ernst Marc O
Department of Cognitive Neuroscience, Universität Bielefeld, Universitätsstraße 25, 33615, Bielefeld, Germany.
Cognitive Interaction Technology (CITEC) Center of Excellence, Universität Bielefeld, Bielefeld, Germany.
Exp Brain Res. 2015 Dec;233(12):3367-77. doi: 10.1007/s00221-015-4403-9. Epub 2015 Aug 18.
When repeatedly switching between two visuomotor mappings, e.g. in a reaching or pointing task, adaptation tends to speed up over time. That is, when the error in the feedback corresponds to a mapping switch, fast adaptation occurs. Yet, what is learned, the relative error or the absolute mappings? When switching between mappings, errors with a size corresponding to the relative difference between the mappings will occur more often than other large errors. Thus, we could learn to correct more for errors with this familiar size (Error Learning). On the other hand, it has been shown that the human visuomotor system can store several absolute visuomotor mappings (Mapping Learning) and can use associated contextual cues to retrieve them. Thus, when contextual information is present, no error feedback is needed to switch between mappings. Using a rapid pointing task, we investigated how these two types of learning may each contribute when repeatedly switching between mappings in the absence of task-irrelevant contextual cues. After training, we examined how participants changed their behaviour when a single error probe indicated either the often-experienced error (Error Learning) or one of the previously experienced absolute mappings (Mapping Learning). Results were consistent with Mapping Learning despite the relative nature of the error information in the feedback. This shows that errors in the feedback can have a double role in visuomotor behaviour: they drive the general adaptation process by making corrections possible on subsequent movements, as well as serve as contextual cues that can signal a learned absolute mapping.
当在两种视觉运动映射之间反复切换时,例如在伸手或指向任务中,随着时间的推移适应往往会加速。也就是说,当反馈中的误差对应于映射切换时,就会发生快速适应。然而,学到的是相对误差还是绝对映射呢?在映射之间切换时,大小与映射之间相对差异对应的误差比其他大误差更常出现。因此,我们可能学会更多地针对这种常见大小的误差进行校正(误差学习)。另一方面,研究表明人类视觉运动系统可以存储多个绝对视觉运动映射(映射学习),并可以使用相关的上下文线索来检索它们。因此,当存在上下文信息时,在映射之间切换不需要误差反馈。我们使用快速指向任务,研究了在没有与任务无关的上下文线索的情况下,当在映射之间反复切换时这两种学习类型各自可能如何起作用。训练后,我们检查了参与者在单个误差探针指示经常经历的误差(误差学习)或先前经历的绝对映射之一(映射学习)时如何改变他们的行为。尽管反馈中的误差信息具有相对性,但结果与映射学习一致。这表明反馈中的误差在视觉运动行为中可以起到双重作用:它们通过使后续运动的校正成为可能来驱动一般适应过程,同时还作为可以指示所学绝对映射的上下文线索。