Coene A, Crevecoeur G, Leliaert J, Dupré L
Department of Electrical Energy, Systems and Automation, Ghent University, Zwijnaarde 9052, Belgium.
Department of Electrical Energy, Systems and Automation, Ghent University, Zwijnaarde 9052, Belgium and Department of Solid State Sciences, Ghent University, Ghent 9000, Belgium.
Med Phys. 2015 Sep;42(9):5007-14. doi: 10.1118/1.4927374.
Magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) are an important asset in many biomedical applications. An effective working of these applications requires an accurate knowledge of the spatial MNP distribution. A promising, noninvasive, and sensitive technique to visualize MNP distributions in vivo is electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR). Currently only 1D MNP distributions can be reconstructed. In this paper, the authors propose extending 1D EPR toward 2D and 3D using computer simulations to allow accurate imaging of MNP distributions.
To find the MNP distribution belonging to EPR measurements, an inverse problem needs to be solved. The solution of this inverse problem highly depends on the stability of the inverse problem. The authors adapt 1D EPR imaging to realize the imaging of multidimensional MNP distributions. Furthermore, the authors introduce partial volume excitation in which only parts of the volume are imaged to increase stability of the inverse solution and to speed up the measurements. The authors simulate EPR measurements of different 2D and 3D MNP distributions and solve the inverse problem. The stability is evaluated by calculating the condition measure and by comparing the actual MNP distribution to the reconstructed MNP distribution. Based on these simulations, the authors define requirements for the EPR system to cope with the added dimensions. Moreover, the authors investigate how EPR measurements should be conducted to improve the stability of the associated inverse problem and to increase reconstruction quality.
The approach used in 1D EPR can only be employed for the reconstruction of small volumes in 2D and 3D EPRs due to numerical instability of the inverse solution. The authors performed EPR measurements of increasing cylindrical volumes and evaluated the condition measure. This showed that a reduction of the inherent symmetry in the EPR methodology is necessary. By reducing the symmetry of the EPR setup, quantitative images of larger volumes can be obtained. The authors found that, by selectively exciting parts of the volume, the authors could increase the reconstruction quality even further while reducing the amount of measurements. Additionally, the inverse solution of this activation method degrades slower for increasing volumes. Finally, the methodology was applied to noisy EPR measurements: using the reduced EPR setup's symmetry and the partial activation method, an increase in reconstruction quality of ≈ 80% can be seen with a speedup of the measurements with 10%.
Applying the aforementioned requirements to the EPR setup and stabilizing the EPR measurements showed a tremendous increase in noise robustness, thereby making EPR a valuable method for quantitative imaging of multidimensional MNP distributions.
磁性纳米颗粒(MNPs)在许多生物医学应用中是一项重要资产。这些应用的有效运作需要准确了解MNPs的空间分布。电子顺磁共振(EPR)是一种用于在体内可视化MNPs分布的有前景、非侵入性且灵敏的技术。目前只能重建一维MNPs分布。在本文中,作者提议通过计算机模拟将一维EPR扩展到二维和三维,以实现对MNPs分布的精确成像。
为了找到与EPR测量对应的MNPs分布,需要解决一个反问题。这个反问题的解高度依赖于反问题的稳定性。作者调整一维EPR成像以实现多维MNPs分布的成像。此外,作者引入部分体积激发,即只对部分体积进行成像,以提高反问题解的稳定性并加快测量速度。作者模拟了不同二维和三维MNPs分布的EPR测量并解决反问题。通过计算条件数并将实际MNPs分布与重建的MNPs分布进行比较来评估稳定性。基于这些模拟,作者确定了EPR系统应对增加维度的要求。此外,作者研究了应如何进行EPR测量以提高相关反问题的稳定性并提高重建质量。
由于反问题解的数值不稳定性,一维EPR中使用的方法仅可用于二维和三维EPR中小体积的重建。作者对不断增大的圆柱形体积进行了EPR测量并评估了条件数。这表明有必要降低EPR方法中固有的对称性。通过降低EPR设置的对称性,可以获得更大体积的定量图像。作者发现,通过选择性地激发部分体积,在减少测量量的同时可以进一步提高重建质量。此外,这种激活方法的反问题解对于不断增大的体积退化得更慢。最后,该方法应用于有噪声的EPR测量:使用降低的EPR设置的对称性和部分激活方法,可以看到重建质量提高了约80%,测量速度加快了10%。
将上述要求应用于EPR设置并稳定EPR测量显示出噪声鲁棒性的极大提高,从而使EPR成为多维MNPs分布定量成像的有价值方法。