Wisniewski David, Reverberi Carlo, Momennejad Ida, Kahnt Thorsten, Haynes John-Dylan
Bernstein Center for Computational Neuroscience Berlin, Berlin Center for Advanced Neuroimaging, Collaborative Research Centre SFB 940, Volition and Cognitive Control, Dresden University of Technology, D-01069 Dresden, Germany,
Psychology Department, University of Milano-Bicocca, I-20126 Milan, Italy, Milan Center for Neuroscience, I-20052 Milan, Italy.
J Neurosci. 2015 Sep 9;35(36):12355-65. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4882-14.2015.
Rewards obtained from specific behaviors can and do change across time. To adapt to such conditions, humans need to represent and update associations between behaviors and their outcomes. Much previous work focused on how rewards affect the processing of specific tasks. However, abstract associations between multiple potential behaviors and multiple rewards are an important basis for adaptation as well. In this experiment, we directly investigated which brain areas represent associations between multiple tasks and rewards, using time-resolved multivariate pattern analysis of functional magnetic resonance imaging data. Importantly, we were able to dissociate neural signals reflecting task-reward associations from those related to task preparation and reward expectation processes, variables that were often correlated in previous research. We hypothesized that brain regions involved in processing tasks and/or rewards will be involved in processing associations between them. Candidate areas included the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, which is involved in associating simple actions and rewards, and the parietal cortex, which has been shown to represent task rules and action values. Our results indicate that local spatial activation patterns in the inferior parietal cortex indeed represent task-reward associations. Interestingly, the parietal cortex flexibly changes its content of representation within trials. It first represents task-reward associations, later switching to process tasks and rewards directly. These findings highlight the importance of the inferior parietal cortex in associating behaviors with their outcomes and further show that it can flexibly reconfigure its function within single trials. Significance statement: Rewards obtained from specific behaviors rarely remain constant over time. To adapt to changing conditions, humans need to continuously update and represent the current association between behavior and its outcomes. However, little is known about the neural representation of behavior-outcome associations. Here, we used multivariate pattern analysis of functional magnetic resonance imaging data to investigate the neural correlates of such associations. Our results demonstrate that the parietal cortex plays a central role in representing associations between multiple behaviors and their outcomes. They further highlight the flexibility of the parietal cortex, because we find it to adapt its function to changing task demands within trials on relatively short timescales.
从特定行为中获得的奖励会随着时间的推移而发生变化,而且确实如此。为了适应这种情况,人类需要表征并更新行为与其结果之间的关联。此前的许多研究都集中在奖励如何影响特定任务的处理上。然而,多种潜在行为与多种奖励之间的抽象关联同样也是适应的重要基础。在本实验中,我们使用功能磁共振成像数据的时间分辨多变量模式分析,直接研究了哪些脑区表征了多种任务与奖励之间的关联。重要的是,我们能够将反映任务 - 奖励关联的神经信号与那些与任务准备和奖励预期过程相关的信号区分开来,而在以往研究中这些变量常常相互关联。我们假设参与处理任务和/或奖励的脑区也会参与处理它们之间的关联。候选区域包括背侧前扣带回皮质,它参与将简单动作与奖励联系起来;还有顶叶皮质,已被证明它能表征任务规则和动作价值。我们的结果表明,顶叶下部皮质的局部空间激活模式确实表征了任务 - 奖励关联。有趣的是,顶叶皮质在试验过程中会灵活地改变其表征内容。它首先表征任务 - 奖励关联,随后切换为直接处理任务和奖励。这些发现凸显了顶叶下部皮质在将行为与其结果联系起来方面的重要性,并进一步表明它能够在单次试验中灵活地重新配置其功能。意义声明:从特定行为中获得的奖励很少会随时间保持不变。为了适应不断变化的情况,人类需要持续更新并表征行为与其结果之间的当前关联。然而,对于行为 - 结果关联的神经表征却知之甚少。在此,我们使用功能磁共振成像数据的多变量模式分析来研究此类关联的神经相关性。我们的结果表明,顶叶皮质在表征多种行为与其结果之间的关联中起着核心作用。它们进一步凸显了顶叶皮质的灵活性,因为我们发现它能在相对较短的时间尺度上,在试验过程中根据不断变化的任务需求调整其功能。