Ibrahim Sanaa Abd El-Azeem, Qalawa Shereen Ahmed
Nursing Administration Depart, Faculty of Nursing, Port Said University, Egypt.
Medical-Surgical Nursing Depart, Faculty of Nursing, Port Said University, Egypt.
Nurse Educ Today. 2016 Jan;36:118-23. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2015.08.014. Epub 2015 Aug 28.
Students' incivility in institutions of higher education is a serious issue that faces educators in performing their teaching duties. The negative impacts associated with uncivil classroom behaviors have been found to contribute to the disruption of the learning process and the classroom learning environment, and the deterioration of the faculty-student relationship.
This study assays the incivility level among nursing students, investigates factors affecting student nurses' incivility, and explores the relationship between students' uncivil behavior and factors affecting its occurrence based on the perceptions of students and faculty staff. A descriptive comparative research design included all nursing students (n=186) and faculty staff (n=66) in the Faculty of Nursing, Port Said University. A structured questionnaire was used to collect the data.
The results of the study reflected that less than two thirds of students (60.2%) reported irresponsible behaviors, more than half (55.9%) expressed that they behave inappropriately, and 47.8% of them believed that they behave aggressively. The highest percentage of students (55.4%) recorded a high level of uncivil behavior, while faculty staff recorded a lower level regarding aggressive uncivil student behaviors. Both faculty staff and students agreed that a high level of incivility is affected by the studied factors, including issues related to environmental and study climate, faculty policies, political atmosphere, and faculty staff.
Uncivil students' behavior interferes with academic achievement and leads to a declined curve of ethics for nursing students, who are to be considered a symbol of ethics when dealing with their patients. Based on the study results, activated implementation of faculty policies on uncivil behaviors is recommended. Also, there is an obvious need to train faculty staff members to deal with uncivil and bullying students.
高等教育机构中学生的不文明行为是教育工作者在履行教学职责时面临的一个严重问题。已发现与不文明课堂行为相关的负面影响会导致学习过程和课堂学习环境受到干扰,以及师生关系恶化。
本研究测定护理专业学生的不文明行为水平,调查影响护理专业学生不文明行为的因素,并基于学生和教职员工的认知探讨学生不文明行为与其发生影响因素之间的关系。一项描述性比较研究设计纳入了塞得港大学护理学院的所有护理专业学生(n = 186)和教职员工(n = 66)。使用结构化问卷收集数据。
研究结果表明,不到三分之二的学生(60.2%)报告有不负责任的行为,超过一半(55.9%)表示他们行为不当,47.8%的学生认为自己行为具有攻击性。记录有高水平不文明行为的学生比例最高(55.4%),而教职员工记录的学生攻击性不文明行为水平较低。教职员工和学生都认为高水平的不文明行为受到所研究的因素影响,包括与环境和学习氛围、教师政策、政治氛围以及教职员工相关的问题。
不文明的学生行为会干扰学业成绩,并导致护理专业学生的道德曲线下降,而护理专业学生在与患者打交道时应被视为道德的象征。基于研究结果,建议积极实施关于不文明行为的教师政策。此外,显然需要培训教职员工应对不文明和欺凌学生的情况。