Sawchuk Tyson, Buchhalter Jeffrey
Alberta Children's Hospital, Calgary, AB, Canada; Alberta Children's Hospital Research Institute, Calgary, AB, Canada.
Alberta Children's Hospital, Calgary, AB, Canada; Alberta Children's Hospital Research Institute, Calgary, AB, Canada; University of Calgary, Cumming School of Medicine, Department of Pediatrics, Canada; University of Calgary, Cumming School of Medicine, Department of Clinical Neurosciences, Canada.
Epilepsy Behav. 2015 Nov;52(Pt A):49-56. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2015.08.032. Epub 2015 Sep 24.
The purpose of this study was to better understand the etiologies, features, and care outcomes of psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNESs) in a pediatric setting.
We performed a retrospective analysis of 32 sequentially referred children for suspected PNESs to a neurology psychology service over a 6-year period. After excluding non-PNES paroxysmal events (related to anxiety or migraine), 29 patients were identified with final diagnosis of PNESs. Charts were examined for presenting symptom data, demographics, comorbidities, neurological diagnoses and investigations, as well as psychological assessment, management, and outcome. Treatment consisted of education around diagnosis and of individual psychological treatment, which, in most cases, was cognitive behavioral therapy up to 14 sessions. Additional mental health services including psychiatric medication, family therapy, and admission to day or inpatient treatment were also utilized in a smaller number of cases. Total treatment periods ranged from 4 weeks to 12 months.
The majority of patients identified were adolescent (90%), Caucasian (72%), and female (76%). Preceding psychology referral, point of entry into medical care for PNESs was primarily through the emergency department (66%) or outpatient neurology clinic referral (31%). Whereas 39% of parents described significant internalizing symptoms in their child (BASC-2), patients themselves tended to underreport anxiety or depression as demonstrated by only 16% endorsement on the BYI-II. By contrast, MACI personality assessment response patterns for adolescents demonstrated high levels of psychic tension/anxiety (65%), depressive affect (55%), and maladaptive personality traits including inhibition (45%), submissiveness (35%), and introversion (30%). Appropriate psychological treatment was associated with high rates of full remission (no new events, n=17, 59%) and partial remission (50% or greater reduction in events, n=6, 21%) as self-reported at discharge. Accurate diagnosis and referral to psychology also led to a sevenfold reduction in PNES-related emergency department visits one year after initial psychology visit compared with the preceding year.
This study suggests that appropriate care for PNESs reduces inappropriate medical investigation and therapy, expedites rates of remission, and decreases health-care utilization in a pediatric setting.
本研究旨在更深入地了解儿科环境中心因性非癫痫性发作(PNES)的病因、特征及护理结果。
我们对6年间连续转诊至神经心理学服务部门疑似患有PNES的32名儿童进行了回顾性分析。在排除非PNES发作性事件(与焦虑或偏头痛相关)后,最终确诊29例PNES患者。查阅病历以获取症状数据、人口统计学信息、合并症、神经学诊断与检查,以及心理评估、治疗与结果。治疗包括围绕诊断的教育及个体心理治疗,多数情况下为长达14次的认知行为疗法。少数病例还采用了包括精神科药物治疗、家庭治疗以及日间或住院治疗等额外的心理健康服务。总治疗周期为4周-12个月。
确诊的大多数患者为青少年(90%)、白种人(72%)及女性(76%)。在转诊至心理科之前,PNES患者进入医疗护理的主要途径是急诊科(66%)或门诊神经科转诊(31%)。尽管39%的家长称其孩子存在明显的内化症状(BASC-2量表),但患者自身往往较少报告焦虑或抑郁,仅16%的患者在BYI-II量表上认可此类情况。相比之下,青少年的MACI人格评估反应模式显示出高水平的精神紧张/焦虑(65%)、抑郁情绪(55%)以及包括抑制(45%)、顺从(35%)和内向(30%)等适应不良人格特质。据出院时自我报告,适当的心理治疗与高比例的完全缓解(无新发作,n = 17,59%)和部分缓解(发作次数减少50%或更多,n = 6,21%)相关。与上一年相比,准确诊断并转诊至心理科还使首次心理就诊后一年与PNES相关的急诊科就诊次数减少了七倍。
本研究表明,对PNES进行适当护理可减少不适当的医学检查与治疗,加快缓解率,并降低儿科环境中的医疗保健利用率。