Choi Jai Ho, Jo Kyung Il, Kim Keon Ha, Jeon Pyoung, Yeon Je Young, Kim Jong Soo, Hong Seung Chyul
Department of Neurosurgery, Bundang Jesaeng Hospital, Sungnam, Korea.
Department of Neurosurgery, Samsung Medical Center, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea.
Neuroradiology. 2015 Nov;57(11):1153-61. doi: 10.1007/s00234-015-1597-2. Epub 2015 Sep 28.
We evaluated the relationship between symptomatic and angiographic changes in untreated cavernous sinus dural arteriovenous fistulas (CSdAVFs), focusing on venous drainage patterns.
The clinical and radiologic features of 34 cases of untreated CSdAVF were retrospectively reviewed. We classified venous drainage patterns as type I (only antegrade drainage), type II (combined antegrade drainage and venous reflux), type III (venous reflux without antegrade drainage), or type IV (stasis or occlusion of venous reflux). Symptom changes were categorized as improvement, aggravation of initial symptoms, or symptom pattern change.
Twenty-one patients (61 %) showed symptom changes during follow-up (median, 12; range, 3-151 months). In the symptom improvement group (n = 10), patients who underwent follow-up angiography (n = 4) exhibited spontaneous occlusion. In the symptom aggravation group (n = 4), new venous reflux developed in 2 patients (type I to type II) and spontaneous occlusion in 2 patients (type III to spontaneous occlusion). In the symptom pattern change group (n = 7), 2 patients showed new venous reflux (type I to type II), and 5 showed stasis or occlusion of an engorged ophthalmic vein (type II or III to type IV). Angiographic regression was observed in all type III and IV patients, and cortical venous reflux (CVR) developed in 1 type I patient.
Symptom changes correlated with chronological angiographic changes. Without treatment, most CSdAVFs behaved benignly and had a low incidence of CVR. Therefore, close observation is a possible protocol for managing CSdAVFs that have tolerable symptoms, no CVR, and no antegrade drainage despite aggravation or fluctuation in symptoms.
我们评估了未经治疗的海绵窦硬脑膜动静脉瘘(CSdAVF)的症状与血管造影变化之间的关系,重点关注静脉引流模式。
回顾性分析34例未经治疗的CSdAVF的临床和影像学特征。我们将静脉引流模式分为I型(仅顺行引流)、II型(顺行引流与静脉反流并存)、III型(无顺行引流的静脉反流)或IV型(静脉反流停滞或闭塞)。症状变化分为改善、初始症状加重或症状模式改变。
21例患者(61%)在随访期间出现症状变化(中位数为12个月;范围为3 - 151个月)。在症状改善组(n = 10)中,接受随访血管造影的患者(n = 4)出现了自发闭塞。在症状加重组(n = 4)中,2例患者出现了新的静脉反流(从I型变为II型),2例患者出现了自发闭塞(从III型变为自发闭塞)。在症状模式改变组(n = 7)中,2例患者出现了新的静脉反流(从I型变为II型),5例患者出现了充盈的眼静脉停滞或闭塞(从II型或III型变为IV型)。所有III型和IV型患者均观察到血管造影退缩,1例I型患者出现了皮质静脉反流(CVR)。
症状变化与血管造影随时间的变化相关。未经治疗时,大多数CSdAVF表现为良性,CVR发生率低。因此,对于症状可耐受、无CVR且尽管症状加重或波动但无顺行引流的CSdAVF,密切观察可能是一种可行的处理方案。