Menéndez Cammie Chaumont, Amandus Harlan, Damadi Parisa, Wu Nan, Konda Srinivas, Hendricks Scott
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Division of Safety Research, 1095 Willowdale Road, MS 1811, Morgantown 26505, West Virginia.
University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland.
Crime Sci. 2014 May;3(1). doi: 10.1186/s40163-014-0004-3. Epub 2014 May 9.
Driving a taxicab remains one of the most dangerous occupations in the United States, with leading homicide rates. Although safety equipment designed to reduce robberies exists, it is not clear what effect it has on reducing taxicab driver homicides.
Taxicab driver homicide crime reports for 1996 through 2010 were collected from 20 of the largest cities (>200,000) in the United States: 7 cities with cameras installed in cabs, 6 cities with partitions installed, and 7 cities with neither cameras nor partitions. Poisson regression modeling using generalized estimating equations provided city taxicab driver homicide rates while accounting for serial correlation and clustering of data within cities. Two separate models were constructed to compare (1) cities with cameras installed in taxicabs versus cities with neither cameras nor partitions and (2) cities with partitions installed in taxicabs versus cities with neither cameras nor partitions. Cities with cameras installed in cabs experienced a significant reduction in homicides after cameras were installed (adjRR = 0.11, CL 0.06-0.24) and compared to cities with neither cameras nor partitions (adjRR = 0.32, CL 0.15-0.67). Cities with partitions installed in taxicabs experienced a reduction in homicides (adjRR = 0.78, CL 0.41-1.47) compared to cities with neither cameras nor partitions, but it was not statistically significant.
The findings suggest cameras installed in taxicabs are highly effective in reducing homicides among taxicab drivers. Although not statistically significant, the findings suggest partitions installed in taxicabs may be effective.
在美国,驾驶出租车仍然是最危险的职业之一,凶杀率居高不下。尽管存在旨在减少抢劫的安全设备,但尚不清楚其对降低出租车司机凶杀案有何影响。
收集了1996年至2010年美国20个最大城市(人口超过20万)的出租车司机凶杀案犯罪报告:7个城市的出租车安装了摄像头,6个城市安装了隔离装置,7个城市既未安装摄像头也未安装隔离装置。使用广义估计方程的泊松回归模型在考虑数据的序列相关性和城市内聚类的情况下得出了各城市出租车司机的凶杀率。构建了两个单独的模型进行比较:(1)出租车安装了摄像头的城市与既未安装摄像头也未安装隔离装置的城市;(2)出租车安装了隔离装置的城市与既未安装摄像头也未安装隔离装置的城市。安装了摄像头的城市在安装摄像头后凶杀案显著减少(调整相对风险率=0.11,可信区间0.06 - 0.24),与既未安装摄像头也未安装隔离装置的城市相比(调整相对风险率=0.32,可信区间0.15 - 0.67)。与既未安装摄像头也未安装隔离装置的城市相比,出租车安装了隔离装置的城市凶杀案有所减少(调整相对风险率=0.78,可信区间0.41 - 1.47),但差异无统计学意义。
研究结果表明,出租车安装摄像头对减少出租车司机凶杀案非常有效。尽管差异无统计学意义,但研究结果表明出租车安装隔离装置可能有效。