Wen Feng, Yang Yu, Zhang Pengfei, Zhang Jian, Zhou Jing, Tang Ruilei, Chen Hongdou, Zheng Hanrui, Fu Ping, Li Qiu
a Department of Medical Oncology ; Cancer Center; State Key Laboratory of Biotherapy; West China Hospital; Sichuan University ; Chengdu , China.
b West China Biostatistics and Cost-Benefit Analysis Center; Sichuan University ; Chengdu , China.
Cancer Biol Ther. 2015;16(11):1577-84. doi: 10.1080/15384047.2015.1095398. Epub 2015 Sep 29.
The surprising results published by FIRE-3 revealed that the overall survival (OS) of RAS wild-type metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) patients treated with Cetuximab(Cmab) and FOLFIRI combination was prolonged to 33.1 months. The substantial increase in testing and treatment costs, however, impose a considerable health burden on patients and society. Hence the study was aimed to assess the cost-effectiveness of RAS screening before monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) therapy based on FIRE-3 study. Four groups were analyzed: group 1, patients with KRAS testing treated with Cmab and FOLFIRI; group 2, patients with RAS testing treated with Cmab and FOLFIRI; group 3, patients with KRAS testing treated with bevacizumab(Bmab) and FOLFIRI; group 4, patients with RAS testing treated with Bmab and FOLFIRI. A Markov model comprising 3 health states (progression-free survival, progressive disease and death) was built. The costs were calculated from a Chinese payer perspective, and survival was reported in quality-adjusted life-months (QALMs). Average total lifetime costs ranged from $104,682.44 (RAS-Bmab) to $136,867.44 (RAS-Cmab), while the survival gained varied from 16.88 QALMs in RAS-Bmab to 21.85 QALMs in RAS-Cmab. The cost per QALM was $6,263.86 for RAS-Cmab, $6,145.84 for KRAS-Bmab, $6,201.57 for RAS-Bmab and $6,960.70 for KRAS-Cmab respectively. The KRAS-Cmab strategy was dominated by the other 3 groups. The first-treatment cost of RAS-Cmab was the most influential one to the model. In all, the RAS screening prior to Cmab treatment in mCRC seems to be a cost-effective strategy in the time of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) therapy with the most gained QALMs.
FIRE-3公布的惊人结果显示,接受西妥昔单抗(Cmab)与FOLFIRI联合治疗的RAS野生型转移性结直肠癌(mCRC)患者的总生存期(OS)延长至33.1个月。然而,检测和治疗成本的大幅增加给患者和社会带来了相当大的健康负担。因此,该研究旨在基于FIRE-3研究评估在单克隆抗体(mAbs)治疗前进行RAS筛查的成本效益。分析了四组:第1组,接受KRAS检测并接受Cmab和FOLFIRI治疗的患者;第2组,接受RAS检测并接受Cmab和FOLFIRI治疗的患者;第3组,接受KRAS检测并接受贝伐单抗(Bmab)和FOLFIRI治疗的患者;第4组,接受RAS检测并接受Bmab和FOLFIRI治疗的患者。构建了一个包含3种健康状态(无进展生存期、疾病进展和死亡)的马尔可夫模型。成本从中国支付方的角度进行计算,生存期以质量调整生命月(QALMs)报告。平均终身总成本从104,682.44美元(RAS-Bmab)到136,867.44美元(RAS-Cmab)不等,而获得的生存期从RAS-Bmab的16.88 QALMs到RAS-Cmab的21.85 QALMs不等。RAS-Cmab每QALM的成本分别为6,263.86美元,KRAS-Bmab为6,145.84美元,RAS-Bmab为6,201.57美元,KRAS-Cmab为6,960.70美元。KRAS-Cmab策略被其他3组主导。RAS-Cmab的首次治疗成本对模型影响最大。总体而言,在mCRC中,在进行单克隆抗体(mAbs)治疗时,在Cmab治疗前进行RAS筛查似乎是一种成本效益高的策略,可获得最多的QALMs。