Mukamel Dana B, Ladd Heather, Li Yue, Temkin-Greener Helena, Ngo-Metzger Quyen
Departments of *Medicine, University of California, Irvine, CA †Department of Public Health Sciences, University of Rochester School of Medicine, Rochester, NY ‡Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Rockville, MD.
Med Care. 2015 Nov;53(11):931-9. doi: 10.1097/MLR.0000000000000426.
Racial disparities in access to care and access to high-quality care have been persistent over many decades. They have been documented in all areas of health care, including ambulatory care. Policy initiatives have been implemented to address disparities and close the gaps in care that minorities face. Less is known about the effectiveness of these polices.
To evaluate whether disparities in quality of ambulatory care have abated during the decade of 2000 by answering 2 questions: (1) were there differences in ambulatory care sensitive hospital admissions rates by race?; (2) have these differences been declining over time?
Multivariable linear regressions with fixed county effects and robust SEs of longitudinal panel data.
A total of 4,032,322 discharges in 172 counties in 6 states during 2003-2009.
Prevention Quality Indicators (PQIs) developed by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, by county, and race calculated from the Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project dataset.
In 2003 the overall PQI admission rates were higher for African Americans (around 16.5/1000) than for whites (around 15/1000). By 2009, the overall and the chronic PQI admission rates declined significantly (P<0.01) for whites. They either did not decline or increased for African Americans. Acute PQI rates declined significantly for whites and remained stable for African Americans.
Policies addressing persisting racial disparities in quality of ambulatory care for African Americans should focus on the chronic PQIs. In addition, efforts should be made to improve data quality for race and ethnicity information on hospital discharge data to enable informed policy evaluation and planning.
几十年来,在获得医疗服务和获得高质量医疗服务方面的种族差异一直存在。在包括门诊医疗在内的所有医疗领域都有相关记录。已实施政策举措来解决差异问题并缩小少数群体所面临的医疗差距。但对于这些政策的有效性了解较少。
通过回答两个问题来评估2000年这十年间门诊医疗质量的差异是否有所减轻:(1)门诊医疗敏感型医院入院率按种族是否存在差异?(2)这些差异是否随时间推移而下降?
采用具有固定县效应和纵向面板数据稳健标准误的多变量线性回归。
2003年至2009年期间6个州172个县的4032322例出院病例。
由医疗保健研究与质量局制定的预防质量指标(PQIs),按县以及根据医疗成本和利用项目数据集计算的种族。
2003年,非裔美国人的总体PQI入院率(约16.5/1000)高于白人(约15/1000)。到2009年,白人的总体和慢性PQI入院率显著下降(P<0.01)。非裔美国人的入院率要么没有下降,要么有所上升。白人的急性PQI率显著下降,非裔美国人的则保持稳定。
解决非裔美国人门诊医疗质量方面持续存在的种族差异的政策应侧重于慢性PQIs。此外,应努力提高医院出院数据中种族和族裔信息的数据质量,以便进行明智的政策评估和规划。