Dongier M
Centre de recherche de l'hôpital Douglas, Verdun, Québec.
Can J Psychiatry. 1989 Feb;34(1):49-54. doi: 10.1177/070674378903400113.
The phenomenon of denial of alcohol dependence prevails not only in a majority of alcoholics, but also in the diagnostic and therapeutic behavior of many physicians. The reasons for this neglect of alcohol abuse are reviewed. In particular, value judgments rather than scientific data seem to lead a number of physicians to share the recent views of the U.S. Supreme Court on primary alcoholism: a "willful misconduct" rather than an illness. This dichotomy between primary and secondary alcoholism, simplistic in itself, is part of current attempts to describe a spectrum of alcoholic disorders, some more social, some more biological. The biological underpinnings of abnormal drinking behaviour include various abnormalities of cerebral neurotransmitters: dopaminergic, serotonergic, GABA and endogenous opiate systems among others. These abnormalities are partly genetically determined, pre-existing to alcohol abuse and explaining why "alcoholism runs in families", and partly secondary to alcohol abuse. Their understanding may open the road to the use of specific pharmacological adjuvants in alcoholism treatment, in conjunction with psychotherapy, rehabilitation and self-help programs.
否认酒精依赖的现象不仅在大多数酗酒者中普遍存在,在许多医生的诊断和治疗行为中也很常见。本文回顾了忽视酒精滥用问题的原因。特别是,价值判断而非科学数据似乎导致一些医生认同美国最高法院近期对原发性酒精中毒的看法:这是一种“故意不当行为”而非疾病。原发性和继发性酒精中毒之间的这种二分法本身过于简单化,是当前试图描述一系列酒精性障碍的一部分,有些障碍更具社会性,有些则更具生物学性。异常饮酒行为的生物学基础包括大脑神经递质的各种异常:如多巴胺能、血清素能、γ-氨基丁酸(GABA)和内源性阿片系统等。这些异常部分由基因决定,在酒精滥用之前就已存在,这解释了为什么“酗酒具有家族遗传性”,部分则是酒精滥用的继发结果。对它们的理解可能为在酒精中毒治疗中结合心理治疗、康复和自助项目使用特定的药物辅助治疗开辟道路。