Voorwinden Jan S, Jaspers Jan P C
Department of Medical Psychology, University of Groningen, University Medical Center Groningen, PO Box 30.001, 9700 RB, Groningen, The Netherlands.
J Genet Couns. 2016 Jun;25(3):495-503. doi: 10.1007/s10897-015-9894-9. Epub 2015 Oct 16.
The psychological impact of an unfavorable genetic test result for counselees at risk for hereditary cancer seems to be limited: only 10-20 % of counselees have psychological problems after testing positive for a known familial mutation. The objective of this study was to find prognostic factors that can predict which counselees are most likely to develop psychological problems after presymptomatic genetic testing. Counselees with a 50 % risk of BRCA1/2 or Lynch syndrome completed questionnaires at three time-points: after receiving a written invitation for a genetic counseling intake (T1), 2-3 days after receiving their DNA test result (T2), and 4-6 weeks later (T3). The psychological impact of the genetic test result was examined shortly and 4-6 weeks after learning their test result. Subsequently, the influence of various potentially prognostic factors on psychological impact were examined in the whole group. Data from 165 counselees were analyzed. Counselees with an unfavorable outcome did not have more emotional distress, but showed significantly more cancer worries 4-6 weeks after learning their test result. Prognostic factors for cancer worries after genetic testing were pre-existing cancer worries, being single, a high risk perception of getting cancer, and an unfavorable test result. Emotional distress was best predicted by pre-existing cancer worries and pre-existing emotional distress. The psychological impact of an unfavorable genetic test result appears considerable if it is measured as "worries about cancer." Genetic counselors should provide additional guidance to counselees with many cancer worries, emotional distress, a high risk perception or a weak social network.
对于有遗传性癌症风险的咨询对象而言,不利的基因检测结果所产生的心理影响似乎有限:在检测出已知家族性突变呈阳性后,只有10% - 20%的咨询对象会出现心理问题。本研究的目的是找出能够预测哪些咨询对象在症状前基因检测后最有可能出现心理问题的预后因素。有50%患BRCA1/2或林奇综合征风险的咨询对象在三个时间点完成了问卷调查:收到基因咨询预约的书面邀请后(T1)、收到DNA检测结果后2 - 3天(T2)以及4 - 6周后(T3)。在得知检测结果后不久以及4 - 6周后,对基因检测结果的心理影响进行了检查。随后,在整个群体中考察了各种潜在预后因素对心理影响的作用。对165名咨询对象的数据进行了分析。结果不利的咨询对象并没有更多的情绪困扰,但在得知检测结果4 - 6周后,他们表现出明显更多的癌症担忧。基因检测后癌症担忧的预后因素包括既往存在的癌症担忧、单身、对患癌的高风险认知以及不利的检测结果。既往存在的癌症担忧和既往存在的情绪困扰最能预测情绪困扰。如果将不利的基因检测结果的心理影响衡量为“对癌症的担忧”,那么这种影响似乎相当大。基因咨询师应该为有许多癌症担忧、情绪困扰、高风险认知或薄弱社交网络的咨询对象提供额外的指导。