Hoerzer Stefan, Federolf Peter A, Maurer Christian, Baltich Jennifer, Nigg Benno M
Human Performance Laboratory, Faculty of Kinesiology, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Institute for Sport Science, University of Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Tyrol, Austria; Department of Neuroscience, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway.
PLoS One. 2015 Oct 21;10(10):e0138631. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0138631. eCollection 2015.
Previous research on elderly people has suggested that footwear may improve neuromuscular control of motion. If footwear does in fact improve neuromuscular control, then such an influence might already be present in young, healthy adults. A feature that is often used to assess neuromuscular control of motion is the level of gait asymmetry. The objectives of the study were (a) to develop a comprehensive asymmetry index (CAI) that is capable of detecting gait asymmetry changes caused by external boundary conditions such as footwear, and (b) to use the CAI to investigate whether footwear influences gait asymmetry during running in a healthy, young cohort. Kinematic and kinetic data were collected for both legs of 15 subjects performing five barefoot and five shod over-ground running trials. Thirty continuous gait variables including ground reaction forces and variables of the hip, knee, and ankle joints were computed for each leg. For each individual, the differences between the variables for the right and left leg were calculated. Using this data, a principal component analysis was conducted to obtain the CAI. This study had two main outcomes. First, a sensitivity analysis suggested that the CAI had an improved sensitivity for detecting changes in gait asymmetry caused by external boundary conditions. The CAI may, therefore, have important clinical applications such as monitoring the progress of neuromuscular diseases (e.g. stroke or cerebral palsy). Second, the mean CAI for shod running (131.2 ± 48.5; mean ± standard deviation) was significantly lower (p = 0.041) than the CAI for barefoot running (155.7 ± 39.5). This finding suggests that in healthy, young adults gait asymmetry is reduced when running in shoes compared to running barefoot, which may be a result of improved neuromuscular control caused by changes in the afferent sensory feedback.
先前针对老年人的研究表明,鞋类可能会改善运动的神经肌肉控制。如果鞋类确实能改善神经肌肉控制,那么这种影响可能在年轻健康的成年人中也已存在。常用于评估运动神经肌肉控制的一个特征是步态不对称程度。本研究的目的是:(a) 开发一种能够检测由鞋类等外部边界条件引起的步态不对称变化的综合不对称指数(CAI);(b) 使用该指数研究在健康年轻人群中跑步时鞋类是否会影响步态不对称。对15名受试者的双腿进行了运动学和动力学数据收集,他们分别进行了五次赤足和五次穿鞋的地面跑步试验。为每条腿计算了包括地面反作用力以及髋、膝、踝关节变量在内的30个连续步态变量。对于每个个体,计算右腿和左腿变量之间的差异。利用这些数据进行主成分分析以获得CAI。本研究有两个主要结果。首先,敏感性分析表明,CAI在检测由外部边界条件引起的步态不对称变化方面具有更高的敏感性。因此,CAI可能具有重要的临床应用,如监测神经肌肉疾病(如中风或脑瘫)的进展。其次,穿鞋跑步时的平均CAI(131.2±48.5;平均值±标准差)显著低于赤足跑步时的CAI(155.7±39.5)(p = 0.041)。这一发现表明,在健康年轻成年人中,与赤足跑步相比,穿鞋跑步时步态不对称程度降低,这可能是传入感觉反馈变化导致神经肌肉控制改善的结果。