Mokdad Ali H, Gagnier Marielle C, Colson K Ellicott, Dansereau Emily, Zúñiga-Brenes Paola, Ríos-Zertuche Diego, Haakenstad Annie, Johanns Casey K, Palmisano Erin B, Hernandez Bernardo, Iriarte Emma
Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, 2301 5th Ave, Suite 600, Seattle, Washington, United States of America.
Division of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of California Berkeley, Berkeley, California, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2015 Oct 27;10(10):e0139680. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0139680. eCollection 2015.
Recent outbreaks of measles in the Americas have received news and popular attention, noting the importance of vaccination to population health. To estimate the potential increase in immunization coverage and reduction in days at risk if every opportunity to vaccinate a child was used, we analyzed vaccination histories of children 11-59 months of age from large household surveys in Mesoamerica.
Our study included 22,234 children aged less than 59 months in El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, and Panama. Child vaccination cards were used to calculate coverage of measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) and to compute the number of days lived at risk. A child had a missed opportunity for vaccination if their card indicated a visit for vaccinations at which the child was not caught up to schedule for MMR. A Cox proportional hazards model was used to compute the hazard ratio associated with the reduction in days at risk, accounting for missed opportunities.
El Salvador had the highest proportion of children with a vaccine card (91.2%) while Nicaragua had the lowest (76.5%). Card MMR coverage ranged from 44.6% in Mexico to 79.6% in Honduras while potential coverage accounting for missed opportunities ranged from 70.8% in Nicaragua to 96.4% in El Salvador. Younger children were less likely to have a missed opportunity. In Panama, children from households with higher expenditure were more likely to have a missed opportunity for MMR vaccination compared to the poorest (OR 1.62, 95% CI: 1.06-2.47). In Nicaragua, compared to children of mothers with no education, children of mothers with primary education and secondary education were less likely to have a missed opportunity (OR 0.46, 95% CI: 0.24-0.88 and OR 0.25, 95% CI: 0.096-0.65, respectively). Mean days at risk for MMR ranged from 158 in Panama to 483 in Mexico while potential days at risk ranged from 92 in Panama to 239 in El Salvador.
Our study found high levels of missed opportunities for immunizing children in Mesoamerica. Our findings cause great concern, as they indicate that families are bringing their children to health facilities, but these children are not receiving all appropriate vaccinations during visits. This points to serious problems in current immunization practices and protocols in poor areas in Mesoamerica. Our study calls for programs to ensure that vaccines are available and that health professionals use every opportunity to vaccinate a child.
美洲近期爆发的麻疹疫情受到了新闻和公众的关注,凸显了疫苗接种对人群健康的重要性。为了估计如果利用每一个为儿童接种疫苗的机会,免疫覆盖率可能提高的幅度以及处于风险中的天数可能减少的幅度,我们分析了中美洲大型家庭调查中11 - 59个月龄儿童的疫苗接种史。
我们的研究纳入了萨尔瓦多、危地马拉、洪都拉斯、墨西哥、尼加拉瓜和巴拿马22234名年龄小于59个月的儿童。利用儿童疫苗接种卡计算麻疹、腮腺炎和风疹(MMR)疫苗的接种覆盖率,并计算处于风险中的生存天数。如果儿童的疫苗接种卡显示有一次疫苗接种就诊,但该儿童未按计划接种MMR疫苗,则认为该儿童有一次错过疫苗接种的机会。使用Cox比例风险模型计算与处于风险中的天数减少相关的风险比,同时考虑错过的机会。
萨尔瓦多拥有疫苗接种卡的儿童比例最高(91.2%),而尼加拉瓜最低(76.5%)。卡片记录的MMR疫苗接种覆盖率从墨西哥的44.6%到洪都拉斯的79.6%不等,而考虑错过机会后的潜在覆盖率从尼加拉瓜的70.8%到萨尔瓦多的96.4%不等。年龄较小的儿童错过疫苗接种机会的可能性较小。在巴拿马,与最贫困家庭的儿童相比,高支出家庭的儿童更有可能错过MMR疫苗接种机会(比值比1.62,95%置信区间:1.06 - 2.47)。在尼加拉瓜,与未受过教育的母亲的孩子相比,受过小学教育和中学教育的母亲的孩子错过疫苗接种机会的可能性较小(分别为比值比0.46,95%置信区间:0.24 - 0.88和比值比0.25,95%置信区间:0.096 - 0.65)。MMR疫苗处于风险中的平均天数从巴拿马的158天到墨西哥的483天不等,而潜在的处于风险中的天数从巴拿马的92天到萨尔瓦多的239天不等。
我们的研究发现中美洲在为儿童免疫方面存在大量错过机会的情况。我们的研究结果令人高度担忧,因为这表明家庭带孩子前往了医疗机构,但这些孩子在就诊期间并未接受所有适当的疫苗接种。这指出了中美洲贫困地区当前免疫实践和方案中存在的严重问题。我们的研究呼吁实施相关项目,以确保有疫苗供应,并确保卫生专业人员利用每一个机会为儿童接种疫苗。