Kirigia Joses Muthuri, Ota Martin Okechukwu, Motari Marion, Bataringaya Juliet Evelyn, Mouhouelo Pascal
Research, Publications and Library Services Programme, Health Systems & Services Cluster, World Health Organization, Regional Office for Africa, Brazzaville, Congo.
Health Systems and Services Cluster, WHO Country Office, Kampala, Uganda.
Health Res Policy Syst. 2015 Oct 30;13:61. doi: 10.1186/s12961-015-0054-3.
A number of resolutions of the World Health Assembly and the WHO Regional Committee for Africa call upon African countries and their development partners to make the required investments in national health research systems (NHRS) to generate knowledge and promote its use in tackling priority public health challenges. Implementation of these resolutions is critical for Africa to progress with the rest of the world in achieving the post-2015 health sustainable development goal. This study assesses the current status of some NHRS components in the 47 countries of the WHO African Region, identifies the factors that enable and constrain NHRS, and proposes the way forward.
To track progress in NHRS components and for comparison, a questionnaire that was used in NHRS surveys in 2003 and 2009 was administered in all 47 countries in the African Region. The national health research focal persons were responsible for completing the questionnaire, which had been hand-delivered to them by the WHO country office staff in charge of research, who also briefed them on the survey, went through the questionnaire for clarity, and sought their informed consent.
All the 47 countries responded to the questionnaire, but some did not answer all questions. Of the countries responding to various questions 49 % (23/47) had a national health research policy; 47 % (22/47) had a health strategic plan; 40 % (19/47) had legislation governing research; 53 % (25/47) had a national health research priority agenda; 51 % (24/47) reported having a functional NHRS and a national health research management forum; 91 % (43/47) had an ethical review committee; 49 % (23/47) had hospitals with ethical review committees to review clinical research proposals; 51 % (24/47) had a scientific review committee; 62 % (29/47) had health institutions with scientific review committees; 83 % (39/47) had a national health research focal point; 51 % (24/47) had a health research programme; 55 % (26/47) had a national health or medical research institute or council; 93 % (41/44) had at least one university faculty of health sciences that conducted health research; and 33 % (15/46) had a knowledge translation platform. Forty-seven percent of countries reported having a budget line for research for health in the ministry of health budget. Between 2003 and 2014, the countries with a functional NHRS increased from 30 % to 51 %.
Compared with 2003 and 2009 surveys, our survey found many countries to have made progress in strengthening some of the functions of their NHRS. However, there remains an urgent need for countries without NHRS to establish them and for others to improve the functionality and efficiency of every NHRS component. This is necessary for the national governments to effectively execute their leadership and governance of NHRS and to create an enabling environment within which research for health can flourish.
世界卫生大会及世卫组织非洲区域委员会的多项决议呼吁非洲国家及其发展伙伴对国家卫生研究系统(NHRS)进行必要投资,以生成知识并促进其在应对重点公共卫生挑战中的应用。这些决议的实施对于非洲与世界其他地区一道实现2015年后卫生可持续发展目标至关重要。本研究评估了世卫组织非洲区域47个国家中一些国家卫生研究系统组成部分的现状,确定了促进和制约国家卫生研究系统的因素,并提出了前进方向。
为追踪国家卫生研究系统组成部分的进展情况并进行比较,在非洲区域所有47个国家使用了2003年和2009年国家卫生研究系统调查中使用的问卷。国家卫生研究联络人负责填写问卷,问卷由负责研究的世卫组织国家办事处工作人员亲手递交给他们,这些工作人员还向他们介绍了调查情况,检查问卷以确保清晰明了,并征得他们的知情同意。
47个国家均对问卷做出了回应,但有些国家并未回答所有问题。在回答各种问题的国家中,49%(23/47)有国家卫生研究政策;47%(22/47)有卫生战略计划;40%(19/47)有研究相关立法;53%(25/47)有国家卫生研究优先议程;51%(24/47)报告有运转正常的国家卫生研究系统和国家卫生研究管理论坛;91%(43/47)有伦理审查委员会;49%(23/47)有设有伦理审查委员会以审查临床研究提案的医院;51%(24/47)有科学审查委员会;62%(29/47)有设有科学审查委员会的卫生机构;83%(39/47)有国家卫生研究联络点;51%(24/47)有卫生研究项目;55%(26/47)有国家卫生或医学研究所或理事会;93%(41/44)至少有一个开展卫生研究的大学健康科学学院;33%(15/46)有知识转化平台。47%的国家报告在卫生部预算中有卫生研究预算项目。2**003年至2014年间,有运转正常的国家卫生研究系统的国家从30%增至51%。
与2003年和2009年的调查相比,我们的调查发现许多国家在加强其国家卫生研究系统的一些功能方面取得了进展。然而,仍迫切需要尚未建立国家卫生研究系统的国家建立该系统,其他国家则需提高每个国家卫生研究系统组成部分的功能和效率。这对于各国政府有效履行其对国家卫生研究系统的领导和治理职责,并创造一个有利于卫生研究蓬勃发展的环境而言是必要的。