Wing Deborah A, Rumney Pamela J, Hindra Sasha, Guzman Lizette, Le Jennifer, Nageotte Michael
1 Department of Obstetrics-Gynecology, University of California , Irvine, Orange, CA.
2 Miller Children's and Women's Hospital , Long Beach, Long Beach, CA.
J Altern Complement Med. 2015 Nov;21(11):700-6. doi: 10.1089/acm.2014.0272. Epub 2015 Aug 21.
To evaluate the compliance with and tolerability of daily cranberry capsule ingestion for asymptomatic bacteriuria (ASB) prevention in pregnancy.
A total of 49 pregnant women from two sites were randomly assigned to cranberry or matching placebo, two doses daily, at gestational ages less than 16 weeks. Patients were followed monthly for urinary tract infection until delivery. Up to seven monthly visits were scheduled for each patient. Delivery data were evaluated.
Of 38 evaluable patients, the mean compliance rate over the study period was 82% (range, 20%-100%). This compliance rate and the 74% of patients achieving good (≥75%) compliance were similar between those who received cranberry capsules and placebo. Compliance evaluation revealed that most patients stopped capsule consumption after 34-38 weeks of participation. Multivariate logistic regression and longitudinal analysis showed a significant interaction time effect with cranberry treatment. However, cranberry consumption was not a significant predictor of gastrointestinal intolerance or study withdrawal. Although 30% of patients withdrew for various reasons, only 1 withdrew because of intolerance to the cranberry capsules. Loss to follow-up was mostly due to provider change (9 of 49 [18%]) and therapy disinterest (4 of 49 [8%]). Seven cases of ASB occurred in 5 patients: 2 of 24 (8%) in the cranberry group and 3 of 25 (12%) in the placebo group. No cases of cystitis or pyelonephritis were observed.
One third of pregnant women could not complete the study protocol for various reasons. Compliance with and tolerability of cranberry capsule ingestion appear good; these capsules provide a potentially effective means to prevent ASB in pregnancy. Further studies with large samples are necessary to confirm the findings.
评估孕期每日摄入蔓越莓胶囊预防无症状菌尿(ASB)的依从性和耐受性。
来自两个地点的49名孕妇在妊娠16周前被随机分配至蔓越莓组或匹配的安慰剂组,每日服用两次。每月对患者进行尿路感染随访直至分娩。每位患者计划最多进行7次月度随访。评估分娩数据。
在38名可评估患者中,研究期间的平均依从率为82%(范围为20%-100%)。接受蔓越莓胶囊和安慰剂的患者的依从率以及74%达到良好(≥75%)依从性的患者比例相似。依从性评估显示,大多数患者在参与研究34-38周后停止服用胶囊。多因素逻辑回归和纵向分析显示蔓越莓治疗存在显著的交互时间效应。然而,食用蔓越莓并非胃肠道不耐受或退出研究的显著预测因素。尽管30%的患者因各种原因退出,但只有1名患者因对蔓越莓胶囊不耐受而退出。失访主要是由于更换医疗服务提供者(49例中有9例[18%])和对治疗失去兴趣(49例中有4例[8%])。5名患者发生了7例ASB:蔓越莓组24例中有2例(8%),安慰剂组25例中有3例(12%)。未观察到膀胱炎或肾盂肾炎病例。
三分之一的孕妇因各种原因未能完成研究方案。蔓越莓胶囊摄入的依从性和耐受性似乎良好;这些胶囊为预防孕期ASB提供了一种潜在有效的方法。需要进一步进行大样本研究以证实这些发现。