Watanabe-Galloway Shinobu, Madison Lynda, Watkins Katherine L, Nguyen Anh T, Chen Li-Wu
Department of Epidemiology, College of Public Health, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, Nebraska, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Creighton University, Omaha, Nebraska, USA.
Rural Remote Health. 2015;15(4):3392. Epub 2015 Nov 16.
The nationwide shortage of mental health professionals is especially severe in rural communities in the USA. Consistent with national workforce statistics, Nebraska's mental health workforce is underrepresented in rural and frontier parts of the state, with 88 of Nebraska's 93 counties being designated as federal mental health professional shortage areas. Seventy-eight counties have no practicing psychiatrists. However, supply statistics alone are inadequate in understanding workforce behavior. The objective of this study was to understand mental health recruitment and retention issues from the perspectives of administrators and mental healthcare professionals in order to identify potential solutions for increasing the mental health workforce in rural communities.
The study used semi-structured focus groups to obtain input from administrators and mental health providers. Three separate focus groups were conducted in each of four regions in 2012 and 2013: licensed psychiatrists and licensed psychologists, licensed (independent) mental health practitioners, and administrators (including community, hospital, and private practice administrators and directors) who hire mental health practitioners. The transcripts were independently reviewed by two reviewers to identify themes.
A total of 21 themes were identified. Participants reported that low insurance reimbursement negatively affects rural healthcare organizations' ability to attract and retain psychiatrists and continue programs. Participants also suggested that enhanced loan repayment programs would provide an incentive for mental health professionals to practice in rural areas. Longer rural residency programs were advocated to encourage psychiatrists to establish roots in a community. Establishment of rural internship programs was identified as a key factor in attracting and retaining psychologists. To increase the number of psychologists willing to provide supervision to provisionally licensed psychologists and mental health practitioners, financial reimbursement for time spent in this activity was identified as important.
The present study showed that a comprehensive approach is needed to address workforce shortage issues for different types of professionals. In addition, systemic issues related to reimbursement and other financial aspects must be resolved to strengthen the overall rural mental healthcare delivery system.
美国全国范围内心理健康专业人员短缺的情况在农村社区尤为严重。与全国劳动力统计数据一致,内布拉斯加州农村和边境地区的心理健康劳动力数量不足,该州93个县中有88个被指定为联邦心理健康专业人员短缺地区。78个县没有执业精神科医生。然而,仅靠供应统计数据不足以理解劳动力行为。本研究的目的是从管理人员和心理健康护理专业人员的角度了解心理健康人员的招聘和留用问题,以便确定增加农村社区心理健康劳动力的潜在解决方案。
本研究使用半结构化焦点小组来获取管理人员和心理健康提供者的意见。2012年和2013年在四个地区分别进行了三个独立的焦点小组讨论:执业精神科医生和执业心理学家、执业(独立)心理健康从业者以及招聘心理健康从业者的管理人员(包括社区、医院、私人执业管理人员和主任)。两位评审员独立审查了这些记录以确定主题。
共确定了21个主题。参与者报告称,保险报销率低对农村医疗保健组织吸引和留住精神科医生以及继续开展项目的能力产生负面影响。参与者还建议,加强贷款偿还计划将激励心理健康专业人员在农村地区执业。有人主张延长农村住院医师培训计划,以鼓励精神科医生在社区扎根。建立农村实习计划被认为是吸引和留住心理学家的关键因素。为了增加愿意为临时持牌心理学家和心理健康从业者提供督导的心理学家数量,为此活动所花费时间的经济补偿被认为很重要。
本研究表明,需要采取综合方法来解决不同类型专业人员的劳动力短缺问题。此外,必须解决与报销和其他财务方面相关的系统性问题,以加强农村整体心理健康护理服务体系。