Rajakannan Thiyagu, Safer Daniel J, Burcu Mehmet, Zito Julie Magno
Dr. Rajakannan, Mr. Burcu, and Dr. Zito are with the Department of Pharmaceutical Health Services Research, University of Maryland School of Pharmacy, Baltimore. Dr. Zito is also with the Department of Psychiatry, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore. Dr. Safer is with the Department of Psychiatry and Pediatrics, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore. Send correspondence to Dr. Safer (e-mail:
Psychiatr Serv. 2016 Mar;67(3):289-95. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201500045. Epub 2015 Nov 16.
This study examined national trends between 1999 and 2010 in not otherwise specified (NOS) DSM-IV psychiatric diagnoses and in related medication treatment patterns reported for adults during outpatient physician office visits.
Data on physician office visits by adults (ages 18-64) with a psychiatric diagnosis were from the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey and National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (1999-2010) (N=52,026). Trends for visits with full-criteria diagnoses compared with visits with NOS diagnoses were analyzed for major psychiatric diagnostic groups, physician specialty, and prescribed medications. Population weighted chi square and logistic regression analyses were utilized.
Between 1999-2002 and 2007-2010, the proportion of all mental health visits by adults to office-based physicians that involved an NOS diagnosis increased significantly, from 42% to 50% (p<.001). Significant proportional increases in NOS diagnoses included bipolar disorders NOS (5% to 55%), anxiety disorders NOS (50% to 62%), and mood disorders NOS (.4% to 1.8%). In 2007-2010, NOS visits accounted for a greater proportion of visits to nonpsychiatrists than to psychiatrists (61% and 35%, respectively). Psychotropic medications prescribed during visits increased over time for both full-criteria and NOS diagnoses, but the increase was greater for NOS visits, specifically for antipsychotics, anticonvulsants-mood stabilizers, and lithium. By 2007-2010, psychotropic monotherapy and multidrug regimens were comparable for full-criteria and NOS diagnoses.
The proportion of U.S. physician visits with an NOS psychiatric diagnosis increased to nearly 50% in 2007-2010. The increase raises concerns about the precision of psychiatric diagnoses in community care and about the impact on concomitant medication regimens.
本研究调查了1999年至2010年间,成人在门诊医生办公室就诊时未另作说明(NOS)的《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV)精神科诊断以及相关药物治疗模式的全国趋势。
有关患有精神科诊断的成人(18 - 64岁)医生办公室就诊的数据来自国家门诊医疗护理调查和国家医院门诊医疗护理调查(1999 - 2010年)(N = 52,026)。针对主要精神科诊断组、医生专业和处方药物,分析了符合完整标准诊断的就诊趋势与NOS诊断的就诊趋势。采用了人口加权卡方检验和逻辑回归分析。
在1999 - 2002年至2007 - 2010年期间,成人到门诊医生处进行的所有心理健康就诊中,涉及NOS诊断的比例显著增加,从42%增至50%(p <.001)。NOS诊断比例显著增加的包括未另作说明的双相情感障碍(从5%增至55%)、未另作说明的焦虑障碍(从50%增至62%)以及未另作说明的心境障碍(从.4%增至1.8%)。在2007 - 2010年,与精神科医生相比,非精神科医生的就诊中NOS就诊所占比例更大(分别为61%和35%)。随着时间推移,无论是符合完整标准诊断还是NOS诊断,就诊期间开具的精神药物都有所增加,但NOS就诊的增加幅度更大,特别是抗精神病药物、抗惊厥药 - 心境稳定剂和锂盐。到2007 - 2010年,符合完整标准诊断和NOS诊断的精神药物单一疗法和多药联合治疗方案相当。
2007 - 2010年,美国医生就诊中NOS精神科诊断的比例增至近50%。这一增加引发了对社区护理中精神科诊断准确性以及对伴随药物治疗方案影响的担忧。