任务转移与艾滋病毒检测服务质量:赞比亚一家国家级参考医院的经验
Task-Shifting and Quality of HIV Testing Services: Experiences from a National Reference Hospital in Zambia.
作者信息
Mwangala Sheila, Moland Karen M, Nkamba Hope C, Musonda Kunda G, Monze Mwaka, Musukwa Katoba K, Fylkesnes Knut
机构信息
Virology Laboratory, Department of Pathology and Microbiology, University Teaching Hospital, Lusaka, Zambia.
Centre for International Health, Department of Global Public Health and Primary Care, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
出版信息
PLoS One. 2015 Nov 25;10(11):e0143075. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0143075. eCollection 2015.
BACKGROUND
With new testing technologies, task-shifting and rapid scale-up of HIV testing services in high HIV prevalence countries, assuring quality of HIV testing is paramount. This study aimed to explore various cadres of providers' experiences in providing HIV testing services and their understanding of elements that impact on quality of service in Zambia.
METHODS
Sixteen in-depth interviews and two focus group discussions were conducted with HIV testing service providers including lay counselors, nurses and laboratory personnel at purposively selected HIV testing sites at a national reference hospital in Lusaka. Qualitative content analysis was adopted for data analysis.
RESULTS
Lay counselors and nurses reported confidentiality and privacy to be greatly compromised due to limited space in both in- and out-patient settings. Difficulties in upholding consent were reported in provider-initiated testing in in-patient settings. The providers identified non-adherence to testing procedures, high workload and inadequate training and supervision as key elements impacting on quality of testing. Difficulties related to testing varied by sub-groups of providers: lay counselors, in finger pricking and obtaining adequate volumes of specimen; non-laboratory providers in general, in interpreting invalid, false-negative and false-positive results. The providers had been participating in a recently established national HIV quality assurance program, i.e. proficiency testing, but rarely received site supervisory visits.
CONCLUSION
Task-shifting coupled with policy shifts in service provision has seriously challenged HIV testing quality, protection of confidentiality and the process of informed consent. Ways to better protect confidentiality and informed consent need careful attention. Training, supervision and quality assurance need strengthening tailored to the needs of the different cadres of providers.
背景
随着新检测技术的出现,以及在艾滋病毒高流行国家将任务转移并快速扩大艾滋病毒检测服务规模,确保艾滋病毒检测质量至关重要。本研究旨在探讨不同类别提供者在赞比亚提供艾滋病毒检测服务的经验,以及他们对影响服务质量因素的理解。
方法
在卢萨卡一家国家级参考医院有目的地选择的艾滋病毒检测点,对包括外展咨询员、护士和实验室人员在内的艾滋病毒检测服务提供者进行了16次深入访谈和2次焦点小组讨论。采用定性内容分析法进行数据分析。
结果
外展咨询员和护士报告称,由于门诊和住院环境空间有限,保密性和隐私受到极大损害。据报告,在住院环境中由提供者发起的检测中,坚持知情同意存在困难。提供者认为不遵守检测程序、工作量大以及培训和监督不足是影响检测质量的关键因素。与检测相关的困难因提供者亚组而异:外展咨询员在手指采血和获取足够量标本方面存在困难;一般非实验室提供者在解读无效、假阴性和假阳性结果方面存在困难。提供者一直在参与最近设立的国家艾滋病毒质量保证计划,即能力验证,但很少接受现场监督访问。
结论
任务转移以及服务提供方面的政策转变严重挑战了艾滋病毒检测质量、保密性保护和知情同意过程。需要认真关注更好地保护保密性和知情同意的方法。需要根据不同类别提供者的需求加强培训、监督和质量保证。