White Clare, McIlfatrick Sonja, Dunwoody Lynn, Watson Max
N. Ireland Hospice, Belfast, Northern Ireland.
Institute of Nursing and Health Research, Ulster University, Newtownabbey, Northern Ireland.
BMJ Support Palliat Care. 2019 Jun;9(2):202-208. doi: 10.1136/bmjspcare-2015-000935. Epub 2015 Dec 1.
Project ECHO (Extension for Community Healthcare Outcomes) uses teleconferencing technology to support and train healthcare providers (HCPs) remotely, and has improved care across the USA. A 6-month pilot was trialled in a community palliative care nursing setting to determine if ECHO would be effective in the UK in providing education and support to community hospice nurses (CHN).
The pilot involved weekly 2 hour sessions of teaching and case-based discussions facilitated by hospice staff linking with nine teams of CHN using video conferencing technology. A mixed-methods prospective longitudinal cohort study was used to evaluate the pilot. Each CHN provided demographic data, and completed a written knowledge assessment and a self-efficacy tool before and after the pilot. Two focus groups were also performed after the pilot.
28 CHNs completed the evaluation. Mean knowledge score improved significantly from 71.3% to 82.7% p=0.0005) as did overall self-efficacy scores following the ECHO pilot. Pre-ECHO (p=0.036) and Retro-Pretest ECHO (p=0.0005) self-efficacy were significantly lower than post-ECHO. There was no significant difference between Pretest and Retro-Pretest ECHO self-efficacy (p=0.063). 96% recorded gains in learning, and 90% felt that ECHO had improved the care they provided for patients. 83% would recommend ECHO to other HCPs. 70% stated the technology used in ECHO had given them access to education that would have been hard to access due to geography.
This study supports the use of Project ECHO for CHNs in the UK by demonstrating how a 6-month pilot improved knowledge and self-efficacy. As a low-cost high-impact model, ECHO provides an affordable solution to addressing growing need.
社区医疗成果推广项目(ECHO)利用电话会议技术远程支持和培训医疗服务提供者(HCPs),并已在美国改善了医疗服务。在社区姑息护理环境中进行了为期6个月的试点,以确定ECHO在英国为社区临终关怀护士(CHN)提供教育和支持方面是否有效。
该试点包括每周2小时的教学和基于案例的讨论,由临终关怀工作人员通过视频会议技术与9个社区临终关怀护士团队进行联系。采用混合方法前瞻性纵向队列研究来评估该试点。每位社区临终关怀护士提供人口统计学数据,并在试点前后完成书面知识评估和自我效能工具。试点结束后还进行了两个焦点小组讨论。
28名社区临终关怀护士完成了评估。ECHO试点后,平均知识得分从71.3%显著提高到82.7%(p=0.0005),总体自我效能得分也有所提高。ECHO前(p=0.036)和回顾性预测试ECHO(p=0.0005)的自我效能显著低于ECHO后。预测试和回顾性预测试ECHO的自我效能之间没有显著差异(p=0.063)。96%的人记录了学习上的收获,90%的人认为ECHO改善了他们为患者提供的护理。83%的人会向其他医疗服务提供者推荐ECHO。70%的人表示,ECHO使用的技术使他们能够获得因地理位置原因难以获得的教育。
本研究通过展示为期6个月的试点如何提高知识和自我效能,支持在英国将ECHO项目用于社区临终关怀护士。作为一种低成本、高影响力模式,ECHO为满足不断增长的需求提供了一种经济实惠的解决方案。