Kim Eung Yeop, Shin Dong Hoon, Noh Young, Goh Byeong Ho, Lee Yeong-Bae
Department of Radiology, Gachon University Gil Medical Center, 21, Namdong-daero 774 beon-gil, Namdong-gu, Incheon, 21565, South Korea.
Department of Neurology, Gachon University Gil Medical Center, Incheon, Korea.
Eur Radiol. 2016 Sep;26(9):2974-81. doi: 10.1007/s00330-015-4141-1. Epub 2015 Dec 8.
To compare two selection criteria (noncontrast CT [NCCT] with multi-phase CT Angiography [MPCTA] and CT perfusion [CTP]) for the determination of eligibility for thrombectomy.
We retrospectively enrolled 71 patients who underwent head NCCT, 9.6-cm CTP, and craniocervical single-phase CTA (SPCTA) within 6 hours of onset. The simulated MPCTA was reconstructed from 1-mm CTP images for assessment of collateral circulation. Infarct core (relative CBF < 30 %) and penumbra (Tmax > 6 seconds) volumes were measured. The infarct core < 70 mL with a mismatch ratio > 1.2 (CTP-A), infarct core ≤ 40 mL with a mismatch ratio > 1.8 (CTP-B), and ASPECTS > 5 with good collaterals (50 % ≥ MCA territory) were used to determine eligibility for thrombectomy. SPCTA was compared with the simulated MPCTA for assessment of collaterals.
CTP-B determined that 11 patients were ineligible for thrombectomy, of which three were eligible by NCCT with MPCTA and 6 by CTP-A. CTP-A and CTP-B showed discrepancy in determining eligibility for thrombectomy between NCCT with MPCTA in three patients each, rendering no significant statistical difference (P > 0.05). The number of patients with poor collaterals was significantly higher on SPCTA than MPCTA (n = 22 and 6 respectively; P < 0.0001).
The two imaging selection criteria (NCCT with MPCTA and CTP) were statistically comparable for determining eligibility for thrombectomy.
• Early mechanical thrombectomy improves clinical outcomes. • Noncontrast CT-multi-phase CTA is used for determining eligibility for thrombectomy. • CTP can help to select patients who are eligible for thrombectomy. • Noncontrast CT-multi-phase CTA and CTP are comparable for patient selection. • Multi-phase CTA is more accurate than single-phase CTA for assessment of collaterals.
比较两种用于确定取栓治疗适用性的选择标准(非增强CT[NCCT]联合多期CT血管造影[MPCTA]和CT灌注[CTP])。
我们回顾性纳入了71例在发病6小时内接受头部NCCT、9.6厘米CTP和颅颈单相CT血管造影(SPCTA)的患者。从1毫米CTP图像重建模拟MPCTA以评估侧支循环。测量梗死核心(相对脑血流量<30%)和半暗带(Tmax>6秒)体积。梗死核心<70毫升且错配率>1.2(CTP-A)、梗死核心≤40毫升且错配率>1.8(CTP-B)以及ASPECTS>5且侧支良好(≥50%大脑中动脉区域)用于确定取栓治疗的适用性。将SPCTA与模拟MPCTA进行比较以评估侧支循环。
CTP-B确定11例患者不符合取栓治疗条件,其中3例通过NCCT联合MPCTA符合条件,6例通过CTP-A符合条件。CTP-A和CTP-B在确定取栓治疗适用性方面与NCCT联合MPCTA相比,各有3例患者存在差异,无显著统计学差异(P>0.05)。SPCTA上侧支不良患者的数量显著高于MPCTA(分别为n = 22和6;P<0.0001)。
两种成像选择标准(NCCT联合MPCTA和CTP)在确定取栓治疗适用性方面具有统计学可比性。
•早期机械取栓可改善临床结局。•非增强CT-多期CT血管造影用于确定取栓治疗的适用性。•CTP有助于选择适合取栓治疗的患者。•非增强CT-多期CT血管造影和CTP在患者选择方面具有可比性。•多期CT血管造影在评估侧支循环方面比单相CT血管造影更准确。