Ha Kyoo-Man
Risk Anal. 2016 Jun;36(6):1262-76. doi: 10.1111/risa.12525. Epub 2015 Dec 31.
This article tests the hypothesis that "if redundancy-oriented management has negative aspects, then it could be facilitated by gene-therapy-oriented management." Negative aspects include disadvantages, misjudgments, or miscalculations. The article provides a newly revised principle of disaster management by studying gene-therapy-oriented management. Based on qualitative analysis, redundancy-oriented and gene-therapy-oriented management are analyzed via five variables: governments, business, volunteers, households, and the international community. The article is valuable because an analytical frame on gene-therapy-oriented management is systematically reconceptualized for the field of disaster management via three elements: unhealthy proteins (problems or failed measures), a vector (new or modified solutions), and target cells (positive outcomes). In accepting the hypothesis, the key tenet is that stakeholders have to assist the progress of redundancy-oriented management with gene-therapy-oriented management by paying attention to the genes of each disaster.
本文检验了“如果面向冗余的管理存在消极方面，那么面向基因治疗的管理可以促进它”这一假设。消极方面包括劣势、误判或误算。本文通过研究面向基因治疗的管理，提供了一个新修订的灾害管理原则。基于定性分析，通过政府、企业、志愿者、家庭和国际社会这五个变量对面向冗余的管理和面向基因治疗的管理进行了分析。本文具有价值，因为面向基因治疗的管理的分析框架通过不健康蛋白质（问题或失败的措施）、载体（新的或改良的解决方案）和靶细胞（积极成果）这三个要素，为灾害管理领域进行了系统的重新概念化。在接受该假设时，关键原则是利益相关者必须通过关注每一场灾害的基因，以面向基因治疗的管理协助面向冗余的管理取得进展。
