Bwana Priska, Vojnov Lara, Adhiambo Maureen, Akinyi Catherine, Mwende Joy, Prescott Marta, Mwau Matilu
Kenya Medical Research Institute, Nairobi, Kenya.
Clinton Health Access Initiative, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2015 Dec 31;10(12):e0145586. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0145586. eCollection 2015.
Currently 50% of ART eligible patients are not yet receiving life-saving antiretroviral therapy (ART). Financial constraints do not allow most developing countries to adopt a universal test and offer ART strategy. Decentralizing CD4+ T cell testing may, therefore, provide greater access to testing, ART, and better patient management. We evaluated the technical performance of a new point-of-care CD4+ T cell technology, the BD FACSPresto, in a field methods comparison study.
264 HIV-positive patients were consecutively enrolled and included in the study. The BD FACSPresto POC CD4+ T cell technology was placed in two rural health care facilities and operated by health care facility staff. We compared paired finger-prick and venous samples using the BD FACSPresto and several existing reference technologies, respectively.
The BD FACSPresto had a mean bias of 67.29 cells/ul and an r(2) of 0.9203 compared to the BD FACSCalibur. At ART eligibility thresholds of 350 and 500 cells/ul, the sensitivity to define treatment eligibility were 81.5% and 77.2% and the specificities were 98.9% and 100%, respectively. Similar results were observed when the BD FACSPresto was compared to the BD FACSCount and Alere Pima. The coefficient of variation (CV) was less than 7% for both the BD FACSCalibur and BD FACSPresto. CD4+ T cell testing by nurses using the BD FACSPresto at rural health care facilities showed high technical similarity to test results generated by laboratory technicians using the BD FACSPresto in a high functioning laboratory.
The BD FACSPresto performed favorably in the laboratory setting compared to the conventional reference standard technologies; however, the lower sensitivities indicated that up to 20% of patients tested in the field in need of treatment would be missed. The BD FACSPresto is a technology that can allow for greater decentralization and wider access to CD4+ T cell testing and ART.
目前,符合抗逆转录病毒治疗(ART)条件的患者中有50%尚未接受挽救生命的抗逆转录病毒疗法。资金限制使大多数发展中国家无法采用普遍检测并提供ART的策略。因此,将CD4+ T细胞检测去中心化可能会使更多人能够进行检测、接受ART治疗,并实现更好的患者管理。我们在一项现场方法比较研究中评估了一种新的即时检测CD4+ T细胞技术BD FACSPresto的技术性能。
连续招募264名HIV阳性患者并纳入研究。BD FACSPresto即时检测CD4+ T细胞技术被放置在两个农村卫生保健机构,由卫生保健机构工作人员操作。我们分别使用BD FACSPresto和几种现有的参考技术对配对的手指采血和静脉血样本进行了比较。
与BD FACSCalibur相比,BD FACSPresto的平均偏差为67.29个细胞/微升,r²为0.9203。在ART治疗阈值为350和500个细胞/微升时,确定治疗资格的敏感性分别为81.5%和77.2%,特异性分别为98.9%和100%。将BD FACSPresto与BD FACSCount和Alere Pima进行比较时,观察到了类似的结果。BD FACSCalibur和BD FACSPresto的变异系数(CV)均小于7%。农村卫生保健机构的护士使用BD FACSPresto进行CD4+ T细胞检测,与高功能实验室中使用BD FACSPresto的实验室技术人员得出的检测结果在技术上高度相似。
与传统参考标准技术相比,BD FACSPresto在实验室环境中表现良好;然而,较低的敏感性表明,在现场接受检测的患者中,多达20%需要治疗的患者会被漏诊。BD FACSPresto是一种能够实现更大程度去中心化、让更多人能够进行CD4+ T细胞检测和接受ART治疗的技术。