Yajima Shuichi, Shimizu Hisanori, Sakamaki Hiroyuki, Ikeda Shunya, Ikegami Naoki, Murayama Jun-Ichiro
Department of Health Policy and Management, School of Medicine, Keio University, 35, Shinanomachi, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo, 160-8582, Japan.
Taiho Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., 1-27, Kandanishiki-cho, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo, 101-8444, Japan.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2016 Jan 4;16:2. doi: 10.1186/s12913-015-1253-x.
Various chemotherapy regimens for advanced colorectal cancer have been introduced to clinical practice in Japan over the past decade. The cost profiles of these regimens, however, remain unclear in Japan. To explore the detailed costs of different regimens used to treat advanced colorectal cancer during the entire course of chemotherapy in patients treated in a practical setting, we conducted a so-called "real-world" cost analysis.
A detailed cost analysis was performed retrospectively. Patients with advanced colorectal cancer who had received chemotherapy in a practical healthcare setting from July 2004 through October 2010 were extracted from the ordering system database of Showa University Hospital. Direct medical costs of chemotherapy regimens were calculated from the hospital billing data of the patients. The analysis was conducted from a payer's perspective.
A total of 30 patients with advanced colorectal cancer were identified. Twenty patients received up to second-line treatment, and 8 received up to third-line treatment. The regimens identified from among all courses of treatment in all patients were 13 oxaliplatin-based regimens, 31 irinotecan-based regimens, and 11 regimens including molecular targeted agents. The average (95% confidence interval [95% CI]) monthly cost during the overall period from the beginning of treatment to the end of treatment was 308,363 (258,792 to 357,933) Japanese yen (JPY). According to the type of regimen, the average monthly cost was 418,463 (357,413 to 479,513) JPY for oxaliplatin-based regimens, 215,499 (188,359 to 242,639) JPY for irinotecan-based regimens, and 705,460 (586,733 to 824,187) JPY for regimens including molecular targeted agents. Anticancer drug costs and hospital fees accounted for 50 to 77% and 11 to 25% of the overall costs of chemotherapy, respectively.
The costs of irinotecan-based regimens were lower than those of oxaliplatin-based regimens and regimens including molecular targeted agents in Japan. Using a lower cost regimen for first-line treatment can potentially reduce the overall cost of chemotherapy. The main cost drivers were the anticancer drug costs and hospitalization costs.
在过去十年中,日本已将多种晚期结直肠癌化疗方案引入临床实践。然而,这些方案的成本概况在日本仍不明确。为了探究在实际临床环境中接受治疗的患者在整个化疗过程中用于治疗晚期结直肠癌的不同方案的详细成本,我们进行了一项所谓的“真实世界”成本分析。
进行回顾性详细成本分析。从昭和大学医院的医嘱系统数据库中提取2004年7月至2010年10月在实际医疗环境中接受化疗的晚期结直肠癌患者。化疗方案的直接医疗成本根据患者的医院计费数据计算。该分析是从支付方的角度进行的。
共确定30例晚期结直肠癌患者。20例患者接受了二线以内治疗,8例患者接受了三线以内治疗。在所有患者的所有治疗疗程中确定的方案有13种基于奥沙利铂的方案、31种基于伊立替康的方案和11种包括分子靶向药物的方案。从治疗开始到治疗结束的整个期间,平均(95%置信区间[95%CI])每月成本为308,363日元(258,792至357,933日元)。根据方案类型,基于奥沙利铂的方案平均每月成本为418,463日元(357,413至479,513日元),基于伊立替康的方案为215,499日元(188,359至242,639日元),包括分子靶向药物的方案为705,460日元(586,733至824,187日元)。抗癌药物成本和医院费用分别占化疗总成本的50%至77%和11%至25%。
在日本,基于伊立替康的方案成本低于基于奥沙利铂的方案和包括分子靶向药物的方案。一线治疗使用成本较低的方案可能会降低化疗的总体成本。主要成本驱动因素是抗癌药物成本和住院成本。