Powers Brian W, White Augustus A, Oriol Nancy E, Jain Sachin H
B.W. Powers is an MD/MBA candidate, Harvard Medical School and Harvard Business School, Boston, Massachusetts. A.A. White is professor of medical education and orthopaedic surgery, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts. N.E. Oriol is dean of students and associate professor of anesthesia, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts. S.H. Jain is chief medical officer, CareMore Health System, Cerritos, California.
Acad Med. 2016 Jul;91(7):913-5. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000001074.
African Americans remain substantially less likely than other physicians to hold academic appointments. The roots of these disparities stem from different extrinsic and intrinsic forces that guide career development. Efforts to ameliorate African American underrepresentation in academic medicine have traditionally focused on modifying structural and extrinsic barriers through undergraduate and graduate outreach, diversity and inclusion initiatives at medical schools, and faculty development programs. Although essential, these initiatives fail to confront the unique intrinsic forces that shape career development. America's ignoble history of violence, racism, and exclusion exposes African American physicians to distinct personal pressures and motivations that shape professional development and career goals. This article explores these intrinsic pressures with a focus on their historical roots; reviews evidence of their effect on physician development; and considers the implications of these trends for improving African American representation in academic medicine. The paradigm of "race-conscious professionalism" is used to understand the dual obligation encountered by many minority physicians not only to pursue excellence in their field but also to leverage their professional stature to improve the well-being of their communities. Intrinsic motivations introduced by race-conscious professionalism complicate efforts to increase the representation of minorities in academic medicine. For many African American physicians, a desire to have their work focused on the community will be at odds with traditional paths to professional advancement. Specific policy options are discussed that would leverage race-conscious professionalism as a draw to a career in academic medicine, rather than a force that diverts commitment elsewhere.
与其他医生相比,非裔美国医生担任学术职位的可能性仍然要低得多。这些差异的根源来自引导职业发展的不同外在和内在力量。传统上,改善非裔美国医生在学术医学领域代表性不足的努力主要集中在通过本科和研究生拓展、医学院的多元化和包容性举措以及教师发展计划来改变结构性和外在障碍。尽管这些举措至关重要,但它们未能应对塑造职业发展的独特内在力量。美国暴力、种族主义和排斥的可耻历史使非裔美国医生面临独特的个人压力和动机,这些压力和动机塑造了他们的职业发展和职业目标。本文探讨这些内在压力,重点关注其历史根源;回顾其对医生发展影响的证据;并考虑这些趋势对提高非裔美国医生在学术医学领域代表性的影响。“种族意识专业精神”范式被用来理解许多少数族裔医生所面临的双重义务,即不仅要在自己的领域追求卓越,还要利用自己的专业地位改善社区的福祉。种族意识专业精神引入的内在动机使增加少数族裔在学术医学领域代表性的努力变得复杂。对于许多非裔美国医生来说,希望自己的工作专注于社区的愿望将与传统的职业晋升道路背道而驰。本文讨论了一些具体的政策选择,这些选择将利用种族意识专业精神吸引人们投身学术医学事业,而不是将精力转移到其他地方的一种力量。