Horton Isaiah, Brown Kirsten, Ma Ting-Lan, Wyatt Tasha R
Department of Medicine, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, MD, USA.
Department of Health Professions Education, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, MD, USA.
Perspect Med Educ. 2025 Apr 29;14(1):208-218. doi: 10.5334/pme.1788. eCollection 2025.
In medical education, acts of professional resistance have been studied across all racial and ethnic groups as an antidote to the social harm and injustice festering in medical education. However, not everyone experiences medical education in the same way; some groups experience it quite differently because of their social positions. In particular, Black physicians face anti-Black racism in medical education, which has the potential to shape their resistance in a particular way. This study was designed to understand what professional resistance looks like in Black residents/fellows in North America and how being Black shaped their experiences of resistance.
This qualitative study used Endarkened storywork to understand how Black GME physicians experienced acts of resistance. Endarkened storywork is a Black-centered approach to research and a way of reclaiming authority to create knowledge. It weaves Endarkened feminism, Afrofuturism, and Indigenous storywork to center storytelling as essential to Black ways of being. We conducted 14 semi-structured interviews and analyzed the data using thematic, theoretical, and emergent coding through the constructs of Re-storying, Endarkened Storywork, and Black quilting.
Black trainees' stories of resistance produced three quilting blocks to illuminate their experiences. First, resistance means continuing to exist in medicine despite all of the profession's efforts to eradicate Black physicians. Second, they work tirelessly to improve Black health and facilitate opportunities for the future of Black people to have a career in medicine. Third, their resistance must contend with a long history of anti-Black racism, which takes a significant toll on the emotional and mental well-being of Black trainees in ways that are best described as racial battle fatigue.
For Black trainees, professional resistance is nuanced and calls into the present a long history of anti-Black racism. Their resistance includes occupying space in medicine, securing a future where Black people exist as physicians, and resisting the emotional burden of doing this work. While all forms of professional resistance are worthy of study, researchers should pay particular attention to how it manifests in various racial groups to understand the nuances of different strategies.
在医学教育中,专业抵抗行为已在所有种族和族裔群体中得到研究,作为应对医学教育中不断恶化的社会伤害和不公正现象的一种方法。然而,并非每个人都以相同的方式体验医学教育;由于他们的社会地位,一些群体的体验截然不同。特别是,黑人医生在医学教育中面临反黑人种族主义,这有可能以一种特殊的方式塑造他们的抵抗行为。本研究旨在了解北美黑人住院医师/研究员的专业抵抗行为是什么样的,以及身为黑人如何塑造了他们的抵抗经历。
这项定性研究采用了“黑化故事工作法”来了解黑人毕业后医学教育(GME)医生是如何经历抵抗行为的。“黑化故事工作法”是以黑人为中心的研究方法,也是一种重新夺回创造知识权威的方式。它将黑化女权主义、非洲未来主义和本土故事工作法编织在一起,将讲故事作为黑人存在方式的核心。我们进行了14次半结构化访谈,并通过重新讲述、黑化故事工作法和黑人拼布等结构,使用主题、理论和新兴编码对数据进行了分析。
黑人受训者的抵抗故事产生了三个拼布板块,以阐明他们的经历。首先,抵抗意味着尽管该行业竭尽全力根除黑人医生,但仍要继续在医学领域存在。其次,他们不懈努力改善黑人健康状况,并为黑人未来从事医学职业创造机会。第三,他们的抵抗必须应对长期存在的反黑人种族主义历史,这种历史给黑人受训者的情感和心理健康造成了巨大伤害,这种伤害用“种族战斗疲劳”来形容最为贴切。
对于黑人受训者来说,专业抵抗行为是微妙的,它唤起了反黑人种族主义的悠久历史。他们的抵抗包括在医学领域占据一席之地,确保黑人能够以医生的身份存在的未来,以及抵抗从事这项工作所带来的情感负担。虽然所有形式的专业抵抗行为都值得研究,但研究人员应特别关注它在不同种族群体中的表现方式,以了解不同策略的细微差别。