Telle Olivier, Vaguet Alain, Yadav N K, Lefebvre B, Cebeillac A, Nagpal B N, Daudé Eric, Paul Richard E
Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Unité de Recherche Associée 8204 Géographie-cités, Paris, France.
Institut Pasteur, Functional Genetics of Infectious Diseases Unit, Department of Genomes and Genetics, Paris, France.
PLoS One. 2016 Jan 25;11(1):e0146539. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0146539. eCollection 2016.
Dengue is a major international public health concern, one of the most important arthropod-borne diseases. More than 3.5 billion people are at risk of dengue infection and there are an estimated 390 million dengue infections annually. This prolific increase has been connected to societal changes such as population growth and increasing urbanization generating intense agglomeration leading to proliferation of synanthropic mosquito species. Quantifying the spatio-temporal epidemiology of dengue in large cities within the context of a Geographic Information System is a first step in the identification of socio-economic risk factors.
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: This Project has been approved by the ethical committee of Institut Pasteur. Data has been anonymized and de-identified prior to geolocalisation and analysis. A GIS was developed for Delhi, enabling typological characterization of the urban environment. Dengue cases identified in the Delhi surveillance system from 2008 to 2010 were collated, localised and embedded within this GIS. The spatio-temporal distribution of dengue cases and extent of clustering were analyzed. Increasing distance from the forest in Delhi reduced the risk of occurrence of a dengue case. Proximity to a hospital did not increase risk of a notified dengue case. Overall, there was high heterogeneity in incidence rate within areas with the same socio-economical profiles and substantial inter-annual variability. Dengue affected the poorest areas with high density of humans, but rich areas were also found to be infected, potentially because of their central location with respect to the daily mobility network of Delhi. Dengue cases were highly clustered in space and there was a strong relationship between the time of introduction of the virus and subsequent cluster size. At a larger scale, earlier introduction predicted the total number of cases.
CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE: DENV epidemiology within Delhi has a forest fire signature. The stochastic nature of this invasion process likely smothers any detectable socio-economic risk factors. However, the significant finding that the size of the dengue case cluster depends on the timing of its emergence emphasizes the need for early case detection and implementation of effective mosquito control. A better understanding of the role of population mobility in contributing to dengue risk could also help focus control on areas at particular risk of dengue virus importation.
登革热是一个重大的国际公共卫生问题,是最重要的节肢动物传播疾病之一。超过35亿人有感染登革热的风险,据估计每年有3.9亿例登革热感染病例。这种大量增加与社会变化有关,如人口增长和城市化加剧导致人口高度聚集,进而导致嗜人蚊种的繁殖。在地理信息系统的背景下量化大城市登革热的时空流行病学是识别社会经济风险因素的第一步。
方法/主要发现:本项目已获得巴斯德研究所伦理委员会的批准。在进行地理定位和分析之前,数据已进行匿名化和去识别处理。为德里开发了一个地理信息系统,能够对城市环境进行类型学特征描述。整理了2008年至2010年德里监测系统中识别出的登革热病例,将其定位并嵌入到这个地理信息系统中。分析了登革热病例的时空分布以及聚集程度。在德里,与森林距离增加会降低登革热病例发生的风险。靠近医院并不会增加报告的登革热病例风险。总体而言,在具有相同社会经济特征的区域内发病率存在高度异质性,且年际变化很大。登革热影响了人类密度高的最贫困地区,但富裕地区也有感染情况,这可能是因为它们在德里日常流动网络中的中心位置。登革热病例在空间上高度聚集,病毒引入时间与随后的聚集规模之间存在很强的关系。在更大尺度上,较早引入预测了病例总数。
结论/意义:德里的登革热病毒流行病学具有森林火灾特征。这种入侵过程的随机性可能掩盖了任何可检测到的社会经济风险因素。然而,登革热病例聚集规模取决于其出现时间这一重要发现强调了早期病例检测和实施有效蚊虫控制的必要性。更好地理解人口流动在登革热风险中的作用也有助于将控制重点放在登革热病毒输入特别危险的地区。