Zhang Xiao-Feng, Thompson Mark, Xu Yi-Hua
Department of Health Toxicology, Public Health School, Harbin Medical University, Harbin, China.
DWB Consulting Services, Prince George, BC, Canada.
Lab Invest. 2016 May;96(5):496-507. doi: 10.1038/labinvest.2015.161. Epub 2016 Feb 1.
Laboratory studies involving repeated exposure to paraquat (PQ) in different animal models can induce many of the pathological features of Parkinson's disease (PD), such as the loss of dopaminergic neurons in the nigrostriatal dopamine system. Epidemiological studies identify an increased risk of developing PD in human populations living in areas where PQ exposure is likely to occur and among workers lacking appropriate protective equipment. The mechanisms involved in developing PD may not be due to any single cause, but rather a multifactorial situation may exist where PQ exposure may cause PD in some circumstances. Multifactorial theory is adopted into this review that includes a number of sub-cellular mechanisms to explain the pathogenesis of PD. The theory is placed into an environmental context of chronic low-dose exposure to PQ that consequently acts as an oxidative stress inducer. Oxidative stress and the metabolic processes of PQ-inducing excitotoxicity, α-synuclein aggregate formation, autophagy, alteration of dopamine catabolism, and inactivation of tyrosine hydroxylase are positioned as causes for the loss of dopaminergic cells. The environmental context and biochemistry of PQ in soils, water, and organisms is also reviewed to identify potential routes that can lead to chronic rates of low-dose exposure that would replicate the type of response that is observed in animal models, epidemiological studies, and other types of laboratory investigations involving PQ exposure. The purpose of this review is to synthesize key relations and summarize hypotheses linking PD to PQ exposure by using the multifactorial approach. Recommendations are given to integrate laboratory methods to the environmental context as a means to improve on experimental design. The multifactorial approach is necessary for conducting valid tests of causal relations, for understanding of potential relations between PD and PQ exposure, and may prevent further delay in solving what has proven to be an evasive etiological problem.
在不同动物模型中进行的涉及反复接触百草枯(PQ)的实验室研究,可诱发帕金森病(PD)的许多病理特征,如黑质纹状体多巴胺系统中多巴胺能神经元的丧失。流行病学研究表明,生活在可能接触PQ地区的人群以及缺乏适当防护设备的工人中,患PD的风险增加。PD发病机制可能并非单一原因所致,而是可能存在多因素情况,即PQ暴露在某些情况下可能导致PD。本综述采用多因素理论,其中包括一些亚细胞机制来解释PD的发病机制。该理论置于慢性低剂量接触PQ的环境背景下,PQ因此作为氧化应激诱导剂。氧化应激以及PQ诱导兴奋性毒性、α-突触核蛋白聚集体形成、自噬、多巴胺分解代谢改变和酪氨酸羟化酶失活的代谢过程,被认为是多巴胺能细胞丧失的原因。本文还综述了土壤、水和生物体中PQ的环境背景及生物化学,以确定可能导致慢性低剂量接触率的潜在途径,这种接触率会重现动物模型、流行病学研究以及其他涉及PQ暴露的实验室研究中观察到的反应类型。本综述的目的是通过多因素方法综合关键关系,并总结将PD与PQ暴露联系起来的假设。本文给出了将实验室方法与环境背景相结合的建议,作为改进实验设计的一种手段。多因素方法对于进行因果关系的有效测试、理解PD与PQ暴露之间的潜在关系是必要的,并且可能防止在解决这一已被证明难以捉摸的病因问题上进一步拖延。