Bonfill Xavier, Osorio Dimelza, Solà Ivan, Pijoan Jose Ignacio, Balasso Valentina, Quintana Maria Jesús, Puig Teresa, Bolibar Ignasi, Urrútia Gerard, Zamora Javier, Emparanza José Ignacio, Gómez de la Cámara Agustín, Ferreira-González Ignacio
Clinical Epidemiology and Public Health, Institute of Biomedical Research (IIB Sant Pau)-Iberoamerican Cochrane Centre, Barcelona, Spain.
CIBER de Epidemiología y Salud Pública (CIBERESP), Madrid, Spain.
PLoS One. 2016 Feb 3;11(2):e0147943. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0147943. eCollection 2016.
To describe the development of a novel on-line database aimed to serve as a source of information concerning healthcare interventions appraised for their clinical value and appropriateness by several initiatives worldwide, and to present a retrospective analysis of the appraisals already included in the database.
Database development and a retrospective analysis. The database DianaHealth.com is already on-line and it is regularly updated, independent, open access and available in English and Spanish. Initiatives are identified in medical news, in article references, and by contacting experts in the field. We include appraisals in the form of clinical recommendations, expert analyses, conclusions from systematic reviews, and original research that label any health care intervention as low-value or inappropriate. We obtain the information necessary to classify the appraisals according to type of intervention, specialties involved, publication year, authoring initiative, and key words. The database is accessible through a search engine which retrieves a list of appraisals and a link to the website where they were published. DianaHealth.com also provides a brief description of the initiatives and a section where users can report new appraisals or suggest new initiatives. From January 2014 to July 2015, the on-line database included 2940 appraisals from 22 initiatives: eleven campaigns gathering clinical recommendations from scientific societies, five sets of conclusions from literature review, three sets of recommendations from guidelines, two collections of articles on low clinical value in medical journals, and an initiative of our own.
We have developed an open access on-line database of appraisals about healthcare interventions considered of low clinical value or inappropriate. DianaHealth.com could help physicians and other stakeholders make better decisions concerning patient care and healthcare systems sustainability. Future efforts should be focused on assessing the impact of these appraisals in the clinical practice.
描述一个新型在线数据库的开发情况,该数据库旨在作为一个信息源,提供有关全球多项举措所评估的医疗保健干预措施的临床价值和适宜性的信息,并对数据库中已收录的评估进行回顾性分析。
数据库开发及回顾性分析。DianaHealth.com数据库已上线且定期更新,具有独立性、开放获取性,提供英文和西班牙文版本。通过医学新闻、文章参考文献以及联系该领域专家来确定各项举措。我们收录的评估形式包括临床推荐、专家分析、系统评价结论以及将任何医疗保健干预措施标记为低价值或不适当的原创研究。我们获取根据干预类型、涉及的专业、出版年份、发起倡议机构以及关键词对评估进行分类所需的信息。该数据库可通过搜索引擎访问,检索出评估列表以及评估所发表网站的链接。DianaHealth.com还提供了对各项举措的简要描述以及一个用户可以报告新评估或建议新举措的板块。从2014年1月至2015年7月,该在线数据库包含来自22项举措的2940项评估:11项收集科学协会临床推荐的活动、5套文献综述结论、3套指南推荐、2组医学期刊上关于低临床价值的文章集以及我们自己发起的一项活动。
我们开发了一个关于被认为临床价值低或不适当的医疗保健干预措施评估的开放获取在线数据库。DianaHealth.com可以帮助医生和其他利益相关者在患者护理和医疗系统可持续性方面做出更好的决策。未来的工作应集中在评估这些评估在临床实践中的影响。