Burris J F, Davidov M E, Jenkins P, Rofman B, Ginsberg D, Rosenbaum R, Ryan J R, Jain A K, Mroczek W J
Cardiovascular Center of Northern Virginia, Alexandria 22302.
Arch Intern Med. 1989 Nov;149(11):2437-41.
In this multicenter, double-blind, parallel study, the antihypertensive effects of betaxolol (20 mg once daily) and/or chlorthalidone (25 mg once daily) were analyzed in 186 patients with essential hypertension. Following a 2- to 4-week placebo baseline period, patients were randomized to one of two treatment groups (betaxolol or chlorthalidone) and studied for 6 weeks while receiving single therapy and an additional 6 weeks with a combination of the two agents. Significant decreases from baseline supine diastolic blood pressure (SDBP) were observed in both groups at the end of the single-therapy phase (11 mm Hg in SDBP for betaxolol and 12 mm Hg in SDBP for chlorthalidone); a further significant decrease (7 mm Hg for betaxolol and 8 mm Hg for chlorthalidone in SDBP) was observed from the end of the single-therapy phase to the end of the combination-therapy phase. Changes in supine systolic blood pressure (SSBP) from baseline to the end of the single-therapy phase were 10 mm Hg for the betaxolol and 16 mm Hg for the chlorthalidone group. In all cases, within-group changes were statistically significant. From the end of single therapy to end of combination therapy there was an additional 14-mm Hg and 13-mm Hg reduction in SSBP in the betaxolol and chlorthalidone groups, respectively. Overall, 89% of the randomized patients completed the single-treatment phase (phase I), and 89% of those patients completed the combined therapy phase (phase II). There was no significant difference between treatment groups in the clinical response rate (SDBP at or below 90 mm Hg or a decrease from baseline of at least 10 mm Hg). A substantial percentage of patients completing phase I responded to either single agent (58% for betaxolol and 65% for chlorthalidone). Among patients completing phase II therapy, the combination of the two agents produced a greater response rate (83% for the betaxolol-first group and 85% for the chlorthalidone-first group). In conclusion, both agents were effective and well tolerated. The most frequent adverse events in the single-therapy phase were headache, arthralgia, and dizziness, while bradycardia, rhinitis, arthralgia, and dizziness were most frequent in the combination-therapy phase. The combination of betaxolol (20 mg) and chlorthalidone (25 mg) once daily produced an additive antihypertensive effect regardless of which drug was administered first.
在这项多中心、双盲、平行研究中,分析了倍他洛尔(每日一次,每次20毫克)和/或氯噻酮(每日一次,每次25毫克)对186例原发性高血压患者的降压效果。在2至4周的安慰剂基线期后,患者被随机分为两个治疗组之一(倍他洛尔组或氯噻酮组),接受单药治疗6周,并接受两种药物联合治疗6周。在单药治疗阶段结束时,两组患者的仰卧位舒张压(SDBP)较基线均有显著下降(倍他洛尔组SDBP下降11毫米汞柱,氯噻酮组SDBP下降12毫米汞柱);从单药治疗阶段结束到联合治疗阶段结束,SDBP进一步显著下降(倍他洛尔组下降7毫米汞柱,氯噻酮组下降8毫米汞柱)。从基线到单药治疗阶段结束,倍他洛尔组仰卧位收缩压(SSBP)变化为10毫米汞柱,氯噻酮组为16毫米汞柱。在所有情况下,组内变化均具有统计学意义。从单药治疗结束到联合治疗结束,倍他洛尔组和氯噻酮组的SSBP分别又下降了14毫米汞柱和13毫米汞柱。总体而言,89%的随机分组患者完成了单药治疗阶段(I期),其中89%的患者完成了联合治疗阶段(II期)。治疗组之间的临床缓解率(SDBP降至或低于90毫米汞柱或较基线下降至少10毫米汞柱)无显著差异。完成I期的患者中有相当比例对单一药物有反应(倍他洛尔组为58%,氯噻酮组为65%)。在完成II期治疗的患者中,两种药物联合使用产生了更高的反应率(倍他洛尔优先组为83%,氯噻酮优先组为85%)。总之,两种药物均有效且耐受性良好。单药治疗阶段最常见的不良事件是头痛、关节痛和头晕,而联合治疗阶段最常见的是心动过缓、鼻炎、关节痛和头晕。倍他洛尔(20毫克)和氯噻酮(25毫克)每日一次联合使用产生了相加的降压效果,无论哪种药物先给药。