Brugiavini Agar, Pace Noemi
Department of Economics, University Ca' Foscari of Venice, Cannaregio 873, 30121, Venezia, Italy.
Health Econ Rev. 2016 Dec;6(1):7. doi: 10.1186/s13561-016-0083-9. Epub 2016 Feb 11.
There is considerable interest in exploring the potential of social health insurance in Africa where a number of countries are currently experimenting with different approaches. Since these schemes have been introduced recently and are continuously evolving, it is important to evaluate their effectiveness in the enhancement of health care utilization and reduction of out-of-pocket expenses for potential policy suggestions.
To investigate how the National Health Insurance Schemes (NHIS) in Ghana affects the utilization of maternal health care services and medical out-of-pocket expenses.
We used nationally-representative household data from the Ghana Demographic and Health Survey (GDHS). We analyzed the 2014 GDHS focusing on four outcome variables, i.e. antenatal check up, delivery in a health facility, delivery assisted by a trained person and out-of-pocket expenditure. We estimated probit and bivariate probit models to take into account the issue of self selection into the health insurance schemes.
The results suggest that, also taking into account the issue of self selection into the health insurance schemes, the NHIS enrollment positively affects the probability of formal antenatal check-ups before delivery, the probability of delivery in an institution and the probability of being assisted during delivery by a trained person. On the contrary, we find that, once the issue of self-selection is taken into account, the NHIS enrollment does not have a significant effect on out-of-pocket expenditure at the extensive margin.
Since a greater utilization of health-care services has a strong positive effect on the current and future health status of women and their children, the health-care authorities in Ghana should make every effort to extend this coverage. In particular, since the results of the first step of the bivariate probit regressions suggest that the educational attainment of women is a strong determinant of enrollment, and those with low education and unable to read are less likely to enroll, information on the NHIS should be disseminated in ways that reach those with little or no education. Moreover, the availability of government health facilities in a region is associated with higher likelihood of enrollment in the NHIS. Accordingly, extending geographical access is an important strategy for expanding NHIS membership and improving access to health-care.
在非洲,许多国家目前正在试验不同的方法,因此人们对探索社会医疗保险的潜力有着浓厚兴趣。由于这些计划是最近才推出的,并且仍在不断发展,评估它们在提高医疗保健利用率和减少自付费用方面的有效性,对于提出潜在的政策建议很重要。
调查加纳的国家健康保险计划(NHIS)如何影响孕产妇保健服务的利用和医疗自付费用。
我们使用了来自加纳人口与健康调查(GDHS)的具有全国代表性的家庭数据。我们分析了2014年的GDHS,重点关注四个结果变量,即产前检查、在医疗机构分娩、由经过培训的人员协助分娩以及自付费用。我们估计了Probit模型和双变量Probit模型,以考虑加入健康保险计划的自我选择问题。
结果表明,在考虑加入健康保险计划的自我选择问题后,NHIS参保对分娩前进行正规产前检查的概率、在医疗机构分娩的概率以及在分娩时由经过培训的人员协助的概率有积极影响。相反,我们发现,一旦考虑到自我选择问题,NHIS参保在广泛范围内对自付费用没有显著影响。
由于更多地利用医疗保健服务对妇女及其子女当前和未来的健康状况有很强的积极影响,加纳的医疗保健当局应尽一切努力扩大这种覆盖范围。特别是,由于双变量Probit回归第一步的结果表明,妇女的教育程度是参保的一个重要决定因素,而受教育程度低且不识字的妇女参保可能性较小,因此应通过能够覆盖那些几乎没有或没有受过教育的人的方式来传播有关NHIS的信息。此外,一个地区政府卫生设施的可及性与加入NHIS的可能性较高相关。因此,扩大地理可及性是扩大NHIS成员资格和改善医疗保健可及性的一项重要战略。