Schuster Roseanne C, McMahon Devon E, Young Sera L
a Program in International Nutrition, Division of Nutritional Sciences , Cornell University , Ithaca , NY , USA.
b Division of Nutritional Sciences , Cornell University , Ithaca , NY , USA.
AIDS Care. 2016;28(6):778-94. doi: 10.1080/09540121.2016.1139041. Epub 2016 Feb 17.
Despite significant biomedical and policy advances, 199,000 infants and young children in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) became infected with HIV in 2013, indicating challenges to implementation of these advances. To understand the nature of these challenges, we sought to (1) characterize the barriers and facilitators that health workers encountered delivering prevention of vertical transmission of HIV (PVT) services in SSA and (2) evaluate the use of theory to guide PVT service delivery. The PubMed and CINAHL databases were searched using keywords barriers, facilitators, HIV, prevention of vertical transmission of HIV, health workers, and their synonyms to identify relevant studies. Barriers and facilitators were coded at ecological levels according to the Determinants of Performance framework. Factors in this framework were then classified as affecting motivation, opportunity, or ability, per the Motivation-Opportunity-Ability (MOA) framework in order to evaluate domains of health worker performance within each ecological level. We found that the most frequently reported challenges occurred within the health facility level and spanned all three MOA domains. Barriers reported in 30% or more of studies from most proximal to distal included those affecting health worker motivation (stress, burnout, depression), patient opportunity (stigma), work opportunity (poor referral systems), health facility opportunity (overburdened workload, lack of supplies), and health facility ability (inadequate PVT training, inconsistent breastfeeding messages). Facilitators were reported in lower frequencies than barriers and tended to be resolutions to challenges (e.g., quality supervision, consistent supplies) or responses to an intervention (e.g., record systems and infrastructure improvements). The majority of studies did not use theory to guide study design or implementation. Interventions addressing health workers' multiple ecological levels of interactions, particularly the health facility, hold promise for far-reaching impact as distal factors influence more proximal factors. Incorporating theory that considers factors beyond the health worker will strengthen endeavors to mitigate barriers to PVT service delivery.
尽管在生物医学和政策方面取得了重大进展,但2013年撒哈拉以南非洲地区仍有19.9万名婴幼儿感染了艾滋病毒,这表明在实施这些进展方面存在挑战。为了解这些挑战的本质,我们试图:(1)描述卫生工作者在撒哈拉以南非洲地区提供预防艾滋病毒垂直传播(PVT)服务时遇到的障碍和促进因素;(2)评估运用理论指导PVT服务提供的情况。我们使用关键词“障碍”“促进因素”“艾滋病毒”“预防艾滋病毒垂直传播”“卫生工作者”及其同义词在PubMed和CINAHL数据库中进行检索,以识别相关研究。根据绩效决定因素框架,在生态层面上对障碍和促进因素进行编码。然后,根据动机-机会-能力(MOA)框架,将该框架中的因素分类为影响动机、机会或能力的因素,以便评估每个生态层面内卫生工作者的绩效领域。我们发现,最常报告的挑战发生在医疗机构层面,涵盖了所有三个MOA领域。在大多数研究中,从最直接到最间接,报告比例达到或超过30%的障碍包括影响卫生工作者动机的因素(压力、倦怠、抑郁)、患者机会(耻辱感)、工作机会(转诊系统不佳)、医疗机构机会(工作量过大、物资短缺)以及医疗机构能力(PVT培训不足、母乳喂养信息不一致)。与障碍相比,促进因素的报告频率较低,且往往是对挑战的解决办法(如质量监督、物资供应稳定)或对干预措施的反应(如记录系统和基础设施改善)。大多数研究没有运用理论来指导研究设计或实施。针对卫生工作者多个生态层面互动的干预措施,尤其是针对医疗机构的干预措施,有望产生深远影响,因为远端因素会影响更直接的因素。纳入考虑卫生工作者以外因素的理论将加强减轻PVT服务提供障碍的努力。