Birnie Kate, Thomas Lindsey, Fleming Clare, Phillips Sarah, Sterne Jonathan A C, Donovan Jenny L, Craig Julie
School of Social and Community Medicine, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK.
NHS South Gloucestershire, Bristol, UK.
BMC Res Notes. 2016 Feb 17;9:104. doi: 10.1186/s13104-016-1901-1.
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidance on adult weight management recommends interventions are multi-component. We aimed to assess the implementation and health benefits of a primary care referral to an adult multi-component weight management intervention in a community setting. The intervention was offered through Primary care in National Health Service (NHS) South Gloucestershire, UK, from Oct 2008 to Nov 2010, in partnership with statutory, community and commercial providers. The scheme offered 12 weeks' community based concurrent support of dietary (Weight Watchers, WW), physical activity (Exercise on Prescription, EOP) and behavioural change (motivational interviewing) components to obese adults. Funding was available for 600 places.
Five hundred and fifty nine participants engaged with the intervention, mean age 48 years, 88% female. Mean weight loss for all engagers was 3.7 kg (95 % confidence interval 3.4, 4.1). Participants completing the intervention achieved the largest weight reduction (mean loss 5.9 kg; 5.3, 6.6). Achievement of 5% weight loss was higher in completers (58%; 50, 65) compared to non-completers (19%; 12, 26) and people who only participated in one commercial component of the intervention (either WW or EOP; 19%; 13, 24).
A multi-component weight management programme may be beneficial for weight loss, but a randomized controlled trial is needed to establish effectiveness and to evaluate cost.
英国国家卫生与临床优化研究所(NICE)关于成人体重管理的指南建议干预措施应是多组分的。我们旨在评估在社区环境中,将初级保健转诊至成人多组分体重管理干预措施的实施情况及其对健康的益处。该干预措施于2008年10月至2010年11月在英国南格洛斯特郡国民健康服务体系(NHS)的初级保健机构中提供,与法定、社区和商业机构合作开展。该计划为肥胖成年人提供为期12周的基于社区的饮食(慧俪轻体,WW)、体育活动(处方运动,EOP)和行为改变(动机性访谈)组分的同步支持。有600个名额的资金。
559名参与者接受了该干预,平均年龄48岁,88%为女性。所有参与干预者的平均体重减轻了3.7千克(95%置信区间3.4,4.1)。完成干预的参与者体重减轻最多(平均减轻5.9千克;5.3,6.6)。与未完成者(19%;12,26)和仅参与干预的一个商业组分(WW或EOP)的人(19%;13,24)相比,完成者中体重减轻5%的比例更高(58%;50,65)。
多组分体重管理计划可能有助于减肥,但需要进行随机对照试验来确定其有效性并评估成本。