Sanchez Tiffany R, Perzanowski Matthew, Graziano Joseph H
Department of Environmental Health Sciences, Columbia University, 722 West 168th Street, New York, NY 10032, USA.
Environ Res. 2016 May;147:537-55. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2016.02.009. Epub 2016 Feb 15.
This systematic review synthesizes the diverse body of epidemiologic research accrued on inorganic arsenic exposure and respiratory health effects. Twenty-nine articles were identified that examined the relationship between inorganic arsenic exposure and respiratory outcomes (i.e. lung function, symptoms, acute respiratory infections, chronic non-malignant lung diseases, and non-malignant lung disease mortality). There was strong evidence of a general association between arsenic and non-malignant respiratory illness, including consistent evidence on lung function impairment, acute respiratory tract infections, respiratory symptoms, and non-malignant lung disease mortality. Overall, early life exposure (i.e. in utero and/or early-childhood) had a marked effect throughout the lifespan. This review also identified some research gaps, including limited evidence at lower levels of exposure (water arsenic <100μg/L), mixed evidence of sex differences, and some uncertainty on arsenic and any single non-malignant respiratory disease or pathological process. Common limitations, including potential publication bias; non-comparability of outcome measures across included articles; incomplete exposure histories; and limited confounder control attenuated the cumulative strength of the evidence as it relates to US populations. This systematic review provides a comprehensive assessment of the epidemiologic evidence and should be used to guide future research on arsenic's detrimental effects on respiratory health.
本系统评价综合了有关无机砷暴露与呼吸健康影响的各种流行病学研究。共识别出29篇文章,这些文章研究了无机砷暴露与呼吸结局(即肺功能、症状、急性呼吸道感染、慢性非恶性肺部疾病和非恶性肺部疾病死亡率)之间的关系。有强有力的证据表明砷与非恶性呼吸道疾病之间存在总体关联,包括关于肺功能损害、急性呼吸道感染、呼吸道症状和非恶性肺部疾病死亡率的一致证据。总体而言,生命早期暴露(即子宫内和/或幼儿期)在整个生命周期中都有显著影响。本评价还确定了一些研究空白,包括低暴露水平(水中砷<100μg/L)的证据有限、性别差异的证据不一,以及砷与任何单一非恶性呼吸道疾病或病理过程存在一些不确定性。常见的局限性包括潜在的发表偏倚;纳入文章中结局测量的不可比性;暴露史不完整;以及混杂因素控制有限,削弱了与美国人群相关证据的累积强度。本系统评价对流行病学证据进行了全面评估,应用于指导未来关于砷对呼吸健康有害影响的研究。