Saint Arnault Denise, Shimabukuro Shizuka
University of Michigan School of Nursing, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University, Onna-son, Japan.
West J Nurs Res. 2016 May;38(5):572-95. doi: 10.1177/0193945915625219. Epub 2016 Feb 19.
This research was part of a larger mixed-methods study examining culture, distress, and help seeking. We surveyed 209 Japanese women living in the United States recruited from clinic and community-based sites, and carried out semi-structured ethnographic interviews with a highly distressed subsample of 25 Japanese. Analytic Ethnography revealed that women described themselves as a "self-in-context," negotiating situations using protective resources or experiencing risk exposure. Women experienced quality of life (QOL) when they were successful. However, a related goal of achievingIkigai(or purpose in life) was differentiated from QOL, and was defined as an ongoing process of searching for balance between achieving social and individual fulfillment. Our resulting hypothetical model suggested that symptom level would be related to risk and protective factors (tested for the full sample) and to specific risk and protective phenomenon (tested in the distressed subsample). Thettests in the full sample found that women who were above threshold for depressive symptoms (n= 26) had higher social stressor and lower social support means. Women who were above the threshold for physical symptoms (n= 99) had higher social stressor means. Analysis of the interviewed subsample found that low self-validation and excessive responsibilities were related to high physical symptoms. We conclude that perceived lack of balance between culturally defined, and potentially opposing, markers of success can create a stressful dilemma for first-generation immigrant Japanese women, requiring new skills to achieve balance. Perceptions of health, as well as illness, are part of complex culturally based interpretations that have implications for intervention for immigrant Japanese women living in the United States.
本研究是一项更大规模的混合方法研究的一部分,该研究考察文化、困扰和求助行为。我们对从诊所和社区场所招募的209名居住在美国的日本女性进行了调查,并对25名高度困扰的日本女性子样本进行了半结构化人种志访谈。分析人种志显示,女性将自己描述为“情境中的自我”,利用保护资源应对各种情况或面临风险暴露。女性在成功时体验到生活质量(QOL)。然而,实现“生き甲斐”(或生活目标)这一相关目标与生活质量有所不同,它被定义为在实现社会和个人成就之间寻求平衡的持续过程。我们得出的假设模型表明,症状水平与风险和保护因素(在全样本中进行检验)以及特定的风险和保护现象(在困扰子样本中进行检验)相关。全样本中的t检验发现,抑郁症状高于阈值的女性(n = 26)具有更高的社会压力源和更低的社会支持均值。身体症状高于阈值的女性(n = 99)具有更高的社会压力源均值。对访谈子样本的分析发现,低自我认可和过多责任与高身体症状相关。我们得出结论,在文化定义的、可能相互对立的成功标志之间,感知到的失衡会给第一代移民日本女性带来压力困境,需要新的技能来实现平衡。对健康以及疾病的认知是基于文化的复杂解读的一部分,这对生活在美国的移民日本女性的干预具有启示意义。