Roine Johanna, Uusitalo Liisa, Hielm-Björkman Anna
Faculty of Agriculture and Forestry, Department of Agricultural Sciences, University of Helsinki, 00014 University of Helsinki, P.O. Box 27, Helsinki, Finland.
Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Department of Equine and Small Animal Medicine, University of Helsinki, 00014 University of Helsinki, P.O. Box 57, Helsinki, Finland.
BMC Vet Res. 2016 Feb 20;12:30. doi: 10.1186/s12917-016-0658-z.
The DOGRISK questionnaire is an internet-based ongoing study of canine nutrition, living environment, and disease. Here we aim to assess the performance of the questionnaire using data from the first three years in relation to some descriptive and disease variables. We used associated questions, official register records, test-retest repeatability, and email/mail contact with questionnaire respondents.
Reliability against an official register of gender, season of birth, breed, and results of hip radiography was tested and Cohen's Kappa was between 0.95-0.99. Internal consistencies of hypothyroidism status and dog's age were calculated using Cronbach's Alpha (α = 0.95 and α = 0.99, respectively). Test-retest repeatability of ten variables among 224 participants was analyzed. Gender, season of birth, and born in owner family had Cohen's Kappa > 0.86, color of coat, vaccination status as an adult, other dogs in household, and vaccination status as a puppy had Cohen's Kappa between 0.67-0.80, and body condition score under two months of age and tidiness of household, had Cohen's kappa of 0.45 and 0.42, respectively. In addition, time spent outside had Cohen's kappa of 0.37. Of the owners contacted by email/mail to confirm their dog's atopy/allergy (skin symptoms), 8.9% reported that they had given an incorrect answer (positive predicted value 91%), but only 69% of all reaffirmed positive answers had a diagnosis set by a veterinarian.
Our study showed that owners were diligent with basic information and with the status of three diseases. Cohen's Kappa in the reliability of the test-retest was in most variables at least 0.67. We propose that the descriptive variables and the disease variables be used as such when we generate hypotheses from the DOGRISK data.
DOGRISK问卷是一项基于互联网的关于犬类营养、生活环境和疾病的持续研究。在此,我们旨在利用前三年的数据,针对一些描述性变量和疾病变量评估该问卷的性能。我们使用了相关问题、官方登记记录、重测信度以及与问卷受访者的电子邮件/信件联系。
对性别、出生季节、品种以及髋关节X光检查结果的官方登记记录进行了信度测试,科恩kappa系数在0.95 - 0.99之间。使用克朗巴哈系数(Cronbach's Alpha)计算甲状腺功能减退状态和犬龄的内部一致性(分别为α = 0.95和α = 0.99)。分析了224名参与者中10个变量的重测信度。性别、出生季节以及是否出生在主人家庭的科恩kappa系数>0.8;毛色、成年犬疫苗接种状况、家中其他犬只以及幼犬疫苗接种状况的科恩kappa系数在0.67 - 0.80之间;两个月龄以下犬只的身体状况评分和家庭整洁度的科恩kappa系数分别为0.45和0.42。此外,户外停留时间的科恩kappa系数为0.37。在通过电子邮件/信件联系以确认其犬只特应性/过敏(皮肤症状)的主人中,8.9%报告称他们给出了错误答案(阳性预测值为91%),但在所有再次确认的阳性答案中,只有69%有兽医做出的诊断。
我们的研究表明,主人在基本信息和三种疾病的状况方面较为认真。重测信度中的科恩kappa系数在大多数变量中至少为0.67。我们建议在从DOGRISK数据生成假设时,按原样使用描述性变量和疾病变量。