van Vugt T A G, Geurts J, Arts J J
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Research School CAPHRI, Maastricht University Medical Centre, P.O. Box 5800, 6229 HX Maastricht, Netherlands.
Biomed Res Int. 2016;2016:6984656. doi: 10.1155/2016/6984656. Epub 2016 Jan 21.
Osteomyelitis is a common occurrence in orthopaedic surgery, which is caused by different bacteria. Treatment of osteomyelitis patients aims to eradicate infection by debridement surgery and local and systemic antibiotic therapy. Local treatment increases success rates and can be performed with different antimicrobial bone graft substitutes. This review is performed to assess the level of evidence of synthetic bone graft substitutes in osteomyelitis treatment. According to the PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews, different types of clinical studies concerning treatment of osteomyelitis with bone graft substitutes are included. These studies are assessed on their methodological quality as level of evidence and bias and their clinical outcomes as eradication of infection. In the fifteen included studies, the levels of evidence were weak and in ten out of the fifteen studies there was a moderate to high risk of bias. However, first results of the eradication of infection in these studies showed promising results with their relatively high success rates and low complication rates. Due to the low levels of evidence and high risks of bias of the included studies, these results are inconclusive and no conclusions regarding the performed clinical studies of osteomyelitis treatment with antimicrobial bone graft substitutes can be drawn.
骨髓炎在骨科手术中很常见,它由不同的细菌引起。骨髓炎患者的治疗旨在通过清创手术以及局部和全身抗生素治疗来根除感染。局部治疗可提高成功率,并且可以使用不同的抗菌骨移植替代物来进行。本综述旨在评估合成骨移植替代物在骨髓炎治疗中的证据水平。根据报告系统评价的PRISMA声明,纳入了关于使用骨移植替代物治疗骨髓炎的不同类型的临床研究。这些研究根据其作为证据水平和偏倚的方法学质量以及作为感染根除情况的临床结果进行评估。在纳入的15项研究中,证据水平较弱,15项研究中有10项存在中度至高度偏倚风险。然而,这些研究中感染根除的初步结果显示出有希望的结果,成功率相对较高且并发症发生率较低。由于纳入研究的证据水平较低且偏倚风险较高,这些结果尚无定论,无法就使用抗菌骨移植替代物治疗骨髓炎的已开展临床研究得出结论。