Ravara Barbara, Gobbo Valerio, Carraro Ugo, Gelbmann Lin, Pribyl Jamie, Schils Sheila
Laboratory of Translational Myology of the Interdepartmental Research Center of Myology, Department of Biomedical Science, University of Padova , Italy.
C.N.R. Institute of Neuroscience, Department of Biomedical Science, University of Padova , Italy.
Eur J Transl Myol. 2015 Mar 11;25(2):4910. doi: 10.4081/ejtm.2015.4910.
Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES) has been used extensively over several decades to reverse muscle atrophy during rehabilitation for spinal cord injury patients. The benefits of the technology are being expanded into other areas, and FES has been recently utilized for injury rehabilitation and performance enhancement in horses. Six retired horses (age from 10 to 17 yrs) that had been previously used mainly for dressage riding were selected for this study. Clinical evaluation found epaxial muscle spasms in all horses with minimal to no pelvic extension when manually palpated. FES treatments were performed on the sacral/lumbar region 3 times per week for a period of 8 weeks, obtaining a total of 22 treatments per horse. The Modified Ashworth Scale for grading muscle spasms found a one grade improvement after approximately four FES treatments, indicating improved functional movement of the sacral/lumbar region, supporting the evidence by clinical palpations that a reduction in epaxial muscle spasms occurred. Skeletal muscle biopsies Pre and Post FES treatments were obtained from the longissimus lumborum muscle. Cryosections were stained with a Hemotoxylin-Eosin (H-E), and nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide tetrazolium reductase reaction (NADH-TR). The eventual size change of the muscle fibers were evaluated by morphometry in the H-E and NADH-TR stained cryosections, while in the NADH-TR slides the histochemical density and distribution of mitochondria were also determined. The main results of the morphometric analyses were: 1) As expected for the type of FES treatment used in this study, only a couple of horses showed significant increases in mean muscle fiber size when Pre- vs Post-FES biopsies were compared; 2) In the older horses, there were sparse (or many in one horse) very atrophic and angulated muscle fibers in both Pre- and Post-FES samples, whose attributes and distribution suggests that they were denervated due to a distal neuropathy; 3) The hypothesis of generalized FES-induced muscle fiber damage during epaxial muscle training is not supported by our data since: 3.1) Denervated muscle fibers were also present in the Pre-FES biopsies and 3.2) Only one horse presented with several long-term denervated muscles fibers Post-FES; 4) Preliminary data indicate an increased density and distribution of mitochondria in Post-FES biopsies, suggesting that the clinical improvements in the FES treated horses may be related to daily increased muscle contraction and perfusion induced by FES training. In conclusion, FES in horses is a safe treatment that provides clinical improvements in equine epaxial muscle spasms.
几十年来,功能性电刺激(FES)已被广泛用于脊髓损伤患者康复期间逆转肌肉萎缩。该技术的益处正扩展到其他领域,最近FES已被用于马匹的损伤康复和性能提升。本研究选取了6匹退役马(年龄在10至17岁之间),这些马之前主要用于盛装舞步骑乘。临床评估发现,所有马匹均存在轴后肌痉挛,手动触诊时骨盆伸展最小或无伸展。在骶骨/腰椎区域进行FES治疗,每周3次,为期8周,每匹马共接受22次治疗。改良Ashworth肌肉痉挛分级量表显示,大约经过4次FES治疗后痉挛程度改善了一级,表明骶骨/腰椎区域的功能运动有所改善,支持了临床触诊的证据,即轴后肌痉挛有所减轻。在FES治疗前后从腰最长肌获取骨骼肌活检样本。冰冻切片用苏木精 - 伊红(H-E)染色以及烟酰胺腺嘌呤二核苷酸四唑还原酶反应(NADH-TR)染色。通过形态计量学在H-E和NADH-TR染色的冰冻切片中评估肌纤维的最终大小变化,同时在NADH-TR切片中还测定线粒体的组织化学密度和分布。形态计量分析的主要结果如下:1)正如本研究中使用的FES治疗类型所预期的那样,比较FES治疗前后的活检样本时,只有几匹马的平均肌纤维大小有显著增加;2)在老年马匹中,FES治疗前后的样本中都存在稀疏的(或一匹马中有许多)非常萎缩且成角的肌纤维,其特征和分布表明它们因远端神经病变而失神经支配;3)我们的数据不支持轴后肌训练期间FES普遍导致肌纤维损伤的假设,原因如下:3.1)失神经支配的肌纤维在FES治疗前的活检样本中也存在,以及3.2)只有一匹马在FES治疗后出现了几条长期失神经支配的肌纤维;4)初步数据表明FES治疗后的活检样本中线粒体的密度和分布增加,这表明接受FES治疗的马匹的临床改善可能与FES训练引起的每日肌肉收缩和灌注增加有关。总之,马匹FES是一种安全的治疗方法,可改善马的轴后肌痉挛。