Goossens Eva, Bovijn Lore, Gewillig Marc, Budts Werner, Moons Philip
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, KU Leuven-University of Leuven, Leuven, Belgium; Research Foundation Flanders, Belgium;
Child & Family, Brussels, Belgium;
Pediatrics. 2016 Apr;137(4). doi: 10.1542/peds.2015-2413. Epub 2016 Mar 3.
Breaks in the delivery of health care (ie, [health]care gaps) occur in a large proportion of young people transitioning to adulthood. Developing interventions that prevent adolescents from dropping out of the medical system, as they leave pediatric care, requires an understanding of determinants of care gaps.
To ascertain determinants of care gaps in young people with chronic conditions as they transition to adulthood by performing a systematic literature search.
MEDLINE, CINAHL, and Embase were queried for pertinent peer-reviewed publications.
Primary quantitative or mixed methods studies that aimed to identify determinants of care gaps in young people (aged 10-25 years) diagnosed with complex chronic conditions and written in English, French, or Dutch were selected. Ten publications satisfied these criteria.
For each publication, determinants of care gaps and quantitative results were extracted. Determinants were categorized into 4 groups using thematic analysis. Quantitative results were standardized, and raw data were converted into odds ratios.
Overall, 11 risk factors and 9 protective factors for care gaps were identified. All factors were related to patient characteristics. Demographics, disease-related characteristics, health care services use, and patient health behaviors and beliefs were significant determinants of care gaps in adolescents with chronic conditions.
Large variability in study methods, statistical techniques, and study populations resulted in inconsistent study findings.
This systematic review identified patient-related determinants of care gaps. Unfortunately, the internal and external validity of the study findings are limited, warranting future prospective, multilevel studies that address remaining knowledge gaps.
在很大一部分向成年期过渡的年轻人中,医疗保健服务的中断(即医疗保健缺口)时有发生。开发能够防止青少年在离开儿科护理后退出医疗系统的干预措施,需要了解医疗保健缺口的决定因素。
通过系统的文献检索,确定患有慢性病的年轻人向成年期过渡时医疗保健缺口的决定因素。
对MEDLINE、CINAHL和Embase进行检索,以查找相关的同行评审出版物。
选取旨在确定被诊断患有复杂慢性病的年轻人(10 - 25岁)医疗保健缺口决定因素的主要定量或混合方法研究,且研究需用英文、法文或荷兰文撰写。有10篇出版物符合这些标准。
对于每篇出版物,提取医疗保健缺口的决定因素和定量结果。使用主题分析将决定因素分为4组。对定量结果进行标准化,并将原始数据转换为比值比。
总体而言,确定了11个医疗保健缺口的风险因素和9个保护因素。所有因素均与患者特征相关。人口统计学、疾病相关特征、医疗保健服务使用情况以及患者的健康行为和信念是慢性病青少年医疗保健缺口的重要决定因素。
研究方法、统计技术和研究人群的巨大差异导致研究结果不一致。
本系统评价确定了与患者相关的医疗保健缺口决定因素。不幸的是,研究结果的内部和外部有效性有限,需要未来进行前瞻性的多层次研究来填补剩余的知识空白。