Cameron Daniel J, Pickett Kristen A, Earhart Gammon M, Grahn Jessica A
Brain and Mind Institute, University of Western Ontario , London, ON , Canada.
Occupational Therapy Program, Department of Kinesiology, University of Wisconsin-Madison , Madison, WI , USA.
Front Neurol. 2016 Feb 22;7:19. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2016.00019. eCollection 2016.
Parkinson's disease (PD) adversely affects timing abilities. Beat-based timing is a mechanism that times events relative to a regular interval, such as the "beat" in musical rhythm, and is impaired in PD. It is unknown if dopaminergic medication influences beat-based timing in PD. Here, we tested beat-based timing over two sessions in participants with PD (OFF then ON dopaminergic medication) and in unmedicated control participants. People with PD and control participants completed two tasks. The first was a discrimination task in which participants compared two rhythms and determined whether they were the same or different. Rhythms either had a beat structure (metric simple rhythms) or did not (metric complex rhythms), as in previous studies. Discrimination accuracy was analyzed to test for the effects of beat structure, as well as differences between participants with PD and controls, and effects of medication (PD group only). The second task was the Beat Alignment Test (BAT), in which participants listened to music with regular tones superimposed, and responded as to whether the tones were "ON" or "OFF" the beat of the music. Accuracy was analyzed to test for differences between participants with PD and controls, and for an effect of medication in patients. Both patients and controls discriminated metric simple rhythms better than metric complex rhythms. Controls also improved at the discrimination task in the second vs. first session, whereas people with PD did not. For participants with PD, the difference in performance between metric simple and metric complex rhythms was greater (sensitivity to changes in simple rhythms increased and sensitivity to changes in complex rhythms decreased) when ON vs. OFF medication. Performance also worsened with disease severity. For the BAT, no group differences or effects of medication were found. Overall, these findings suggest that timing is impaired in PD, and that dopaminergic medication influences beat-based and non-beat-based timing differently. Judging the beat in music does not appear to be affected by PD or by dopaminergic medication.
帕金森病(PD)会对时间感知能力产生不利影响。基于节拍的时间感知是一种根据固定间隔对事件进行计时的机制,比如音乐节奏中的“节拍”,而帕金森病患者的这种能力会受损。目前尚不清楚多巴胺能药物是否会影响帕金森病患者基于节拍的时间感知。在此,我们对帕金森病患者(分别在未服用多巴胺能药物和服用药物后)以及未服用药物的对照参与者进行了两个阶段的基于节拍的时间感知测试。帕金森病患者和对照参与者完成了两项任务。第一项是辨别任务,参与者要比较两种节奏并判断它们是否相同。与之前的研究一样,节奏要么具有节拍结构(韵律简单节奏),要么没有(韵律复杂节奏)。分析辨别准确率以测试节拍结构的影响,以及帕金森病患者与对照之间的差异,还有药物的影响(仅针对帕金森病组)。第二项任务是节拍对齐测试(BAT),参与者要听叠加了规则音调的音乐,并回答音调是在音乐节拍的“上”还是“下”。分析准确率以测试帕金森病患者与对照之间的差异,以及药物对患者的影响。患者和对照辨别韵律简单节奏的能力都优于韵律复杂节奏。对照在第二个阶段的辨别任务中比第一个阶段有所提高,而帕金森病患者则没有。对于帕金森病患者,服用药物时与未服用药物时相比,韵律简单节奏和韵律复杂节奏之间的表现差异更大(对简单节奏变化的敏感度增加,对复杂节奏变化的敏感度降低)。表现也随疾病严重程度而恶化。对于节拍对齐测试,未发现组间差异或药物影响。总体而言,这些发现表明帕金森病患者的时间感知能力受损,并且多巴胺能药物对基于节拍和非基于节拍的时间感知的影响不同。判断音乐中的节拍似乎不受帕金森病或多巴胺能药物的影响。