Campbell Oona M R, Cegolon Luca, Macleod David, Benova Lenka
Faculty of Epidemiology and Population Health, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom.
PLoS Med. 2016 Mar 8;13(3):e1001972. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1001972. eCollection 2016 Mar.
Following childbirth, women need to stay sufficiently long in health facilities to receive adequate care. Little is known about length of stay following childbirth in low- and middle-income countries or its determinants.
We described length of stay after facility delivery in 92 countries. We then created a conceptual framework of the main drivers of length of stay, and explored factors associated with length of stay in 30 countries using multivariable linear regression. Finally, we used multivariable logistic regression to examine the factors associated with stays that were "too short" (<24 h for vaginal deliveries and <72 h for cesarean-section deliveries). Across countries, the mean length of stay ranged from 1.3 to 6.6 d: 0.5 to 6.2 d for singleton vaginal deliveries and 2.5 to 9.3 d for cesarean-section deliveries. The percentage of women staying too short ranged from 0.2% to 83% for vaginal deliveries and from 1% to 75% for cesarean-section deliveries. Our conceptual framework identified three broad categories of factors that influenced length of stay: need-related determinants that required an indicated extension of stay, and health-system and woman/family dimensions that were drivers of inappropriately short or long stays. The factors identified as independently important in our regression analyses included cesarean-section delivery, birthweight, multiple birth, and infant survival status. Older women and women whose infants were delivered by doctors had extended lengths of stay, as did poorer women. Reliance on factors captured in secondary data that were self-reported by women up to 5 y after a live birth was the main limitation.
Length of stay after childbirth is very variable between countries. Substantial proportions of women stay too short to receive adequate postnatal care. We need to ensure that facilities have skilled birth attendants and effective elements of care, but also that women stay long enough to benefit from these. The challenge is to commit to achieving adequate lengths of stay in low- and middle-income countries, while ensuring any additional time is used to provide high-quality and respectful care.
分娩后,女性需要在医疗机构停留足够长的时间以获得充分的护理。对于低收入和中等收入国家分娩后的住院时间及其决定因素,人们了解甚少。
我们描述了92个国家在医疗机构分娩后的住院时间。然后,我们创建了一个住院时间主要驱动因素的概念框架,并使用多变量线性回归在30个国家探索了与住院时间相关的因素。最后,我们使用多变量逻辑回归来研究与“过短”住院时间(阴道分娩<24小时,剖宫产分娩<72小时)相关的因素。在各个国家中,平均住院时间从1.3天到6.6天不等:单胎阴道分娩为0.5天到6.2天,剖宫产分娩为2.5天到9.3天。阴道分娩住院时间过短的女性比例从0.2%到83%不等,剖宫产分娩的这一比例从1%到75%不等。我们的概念框架确定了影响住院时间的三大类因素:与需求相关的决定因素,这些因素需要延长住院时间;卫生系统以及女性/家庭层面的因素,这些因素是住院时间过短或过长的驱动因素。在我们的回归分析中确定为具有独立重要性的因素包括剖宫产分娩、出生体重、多胎妊娠和婴儿存活状况。年龄较大的女性以及由医生接生婴儿的女性住院时间延长,贫困女性也是如此。主要局限性在于依赖分娩后长达5年由女性自我报告的二手数据中所包含的因素。
各国分娩后的住院时间差异很大。相当大比例的女性住院时间过短,无法获得充分的产后护理。我们需要确保医疗机构配备熟练的助产人员和有效的护理要素,同时也要确保女性住院时间足够长,以便从中受益。挑战在于致力于在低收入和中等收入国家实现足够的住院时间,同时确保额外的时间用于提供高质量且尊重患者的护理。