From University of Leipzig, Heart Centre, Department of Internal Medicine/Cardiology, Germany (A.M.-W., M.U., V.A., M.S., S.E., K.L., N.M., U.M., J.A., A.P.L., G.S.); Asklepios Clinic Weißenfels, Germany (S.M.-W., K.L.); MediClin Dünenwald Klinik Trassenheide, Germany (M.G., S.B.); Department of Sports Medicine, University Wuppertal, Germany (T.H.); and Coordination Centre for Clinical Trials, University of Leipzig, Germany (M.M.).
Circulation. 2016 Apr 12;133(15):1438-48; discussion 1448. doi: 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.115.016442. Epub 2016 Mar 15.
A well-developed coronary collateral circulation provides a potential source of blood supply in coronary artery disease. However, the prognostic importance and functional relevance of coronary collaterals is controversial with the association between exercise training and collateral growth still unclear.
This prospective, open-label study randomly assigned 60 patients with significant coronary artery disease (fractional flow reserve ≤0.75) to high-intensity exercise (group A, 20 patients) or moderate-intensity exercise (group B, 20 patients) for 4 weeks or to a control group (group C, 20 patients). The primary end point was the change of the coronary collateral flow index (CFI) after 4 weeks. Analysis was based on the intention to treat. After 4 weeks, baseline CFI increased significantly by 39.4% in group A (from 0.142±0.07 at beginning to 0.198±0.09 at 4 weeks) in comparison with 41.3% in group B (from 0.143±0.06 to 0.202±0.09), whereas CFI in the control group remained unchanged (0.7%, from 0.149±0.09 to 0.150±0.08). High-intensity exercise did not lead to a greater CFI than moderate-intensity training. After 4 weeks, exercise capacity, Vo2 peak and ischemic threshold increased significantly in group A and group B in comparison with group C with no difference between group A and group B.
A significant improvement in CFI was demonstrated in response to moderate- and high-intensity exercise performed for 10 hours per week.
URL: http://www.clinicaltrials.gov. Unique identifier: NCT01209637.
良好的冠状动脉侧支循环为冠心病提供了潜在的血液供应来源。然而,冠状动脉侧支循环的预后意义和功能相关性仍存在争议,运动训练与侧支生长之间的关系尚不清楚。
这项前瞻性、开放标签研究将 60 例有明显冠状动脉疾病(血流储备分数≤0.75)的患者随机分为高强度运动组(A 组,20 例)、中强度运动组(B 组,20 例)或对照组(C 组,20 例),进行 4 周的运动治疗。主要终点是 4 周后冠状动脉侧支血流指数(CFI)的变化。分析基于意向治疗。4 周后,A 组的 CFI 基线显著增加 39.4%(从开始时的 0.142±0.07 增加到 4 周时的 0.198±0.09),B 组增加 41.3%(从 0.143±0.06 增加到 0.202±0.09),而 C 组的 CFI 保持不变(0.7%,从 0.149±0.09 增加到 0.150±0.08)。高强度运动并未导致 CFI 增加超过中强度训练。4 周后,A 组和 B 组的运动能力、Vo2 峰值和缺血阈值均显著增加,与 C 组相比有显著差异,而 A 组和 B 组之间没有差异。
每周进行 10 小时的中高强度运动可显著改善 CFI。