Guimaraes Rodrigo Pereira, Saeki de Souza Gilliatt, da Silva Reginaldo Sandro, Ono Nelson Keiske, Honda Emerson Kiyoshi, Polesello Giancarlo Cavalli, Riccioli Walter
MSc from FCMSCSP and Lecturer; Attending physician in the Hip Group, Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology, FCMSCSP.
Orthopedist and former trainee in the Hip Group, Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology, FCMSCSP.
Rev Bras Ortop. 2015 Nov 17;45(4):355-61. doi: 10.1016/S2255-4971(15)30381-5. eCollection 2010 Jul-Aug.
To establish guidelines for the treatment of femoral head fractures and to determine the best form of access in cases treated surgically.
We evaluated the clinical and radiological results from 13 patients (13 fractures) treated surgically, between May 1986 and July 1996, at the Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology, Santa Casa de Misericórdia de Sao Paulo (SCMSP), Fernandinho Simonsen Wing.
Out of six cases of Pipkin 1 fractures, five underwent resection of the fragment, resulting in four excellent and one good result. The good result had fixation of the fragment. Three patients presented Pipkin 2 fractures and all of them had fixation of the fragment, resulting in two excellent and one regular result. Two patients had Pipkin 3 fractures and underwent primary arthroplasty. Among the two patients with Pipkin 4 lesions, one was treated with reduction and osteosynthesis of the acetabular fracture, without addressing the head fragment, which had reduced significantly, resulting in early arthrosis; and the other patient was treated with total arthroplasty as the primary treatment.
Upon comparing the literature review and our patients' treatment results, we concluded that femoral head fracture treatment needs to be surgical and that the choice of surgical access depends on the type of fracture.
制定股骨头骨折的治疗指南,并确定手术治疗病例的最佳入路方式。
我们评估了1986年5月至1996年7月期间在圣保罗慈善医院(SCMSP)费尔南迪尼奥·西蒙森分院骨科与创伤科接受手术治疗的13例患者(13处骨折)的临床和放射学结果。
在6例皮普金1型骨折病例中,5例进行了碎骨片切除术,结果4例为优,1例为良。获得良结果的病例碎骨片得到了固定。3例患者为皮普金2型骨折,所有患者的碎骨片均得到固定,结果2例为优,1例为一般。2例患者为皮普金3型骨折,接受了一期关节置换术。在2例皮普金4型损伤患者中,1例患者接受了髋臼骨折复位及骨合成治疗,未处理股骨头碎骨片,该碎骨片已明显复位,结果出现早期关节病;另1例患者则以全关节置换术作为主要治疗方法。
通过比较文献综述和我们患者的治疗结果,我们得出结论,股骨头骨折的治疗需要手术,手术入路的选择取决于骨折类型。