Toyinbo Oluyemi, Matilainen Markus, Turunen Mari, Putus Tuula, Shaughnessy Richard, Haverinen-Shaughnessy Ulla
National Institute for Health and Welfare, Kuopio FI-70701, Finland.
Faculty of Medicine, Occupational Health Care Unit, University of Turku, Turku 20014, Finland.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2016 Mar 30;13(4):385. doi: 10.3390/ijerph13040385.
The aim of this paper was to examine associations between school building characteristics, indoor environmental quality (IEQ), and health responses using questionnaire data from both school principals and students.
From 334 randomly sampled schools, 4248 sixth grade students from 297 schools participated in a questionnaire. From these schools, 134 principals returned questionnaires concerning 51 IEQ related questions of their school. Generalized linear mixed models (GLMM) were used to study the associations between IEQ indicators and existence of self-reported upper respiratory symptoms, while hierarchical Zero Inflated Poisson (ZIP)-models were used to model the number of symptoms.
Significant associations were established between existence of upper respiratory symptoms and unsatisfactory classroom temperature during the heating season (ORs 1.45 for too hot and cold, and 1.27 for too cold as compared to satisfactory temperature) and dampness or moisture damage during the year 2006-2007 (OR: 1.80 as compared to no moisture damage), respectively. The number of upper respiratory symptoms was significantly associated with inadequate ventilation and dampness or moisture damage. A higher number of missed school days due to respiratory infections were reported in schools with inadequate ventilation (RR: 1.16).
The school level IEQ indicator variables described in this paper could explain a relatively large part of the school level variation observed in the self-reported upper respiratory symptoms and missed school days due to respiratory infections among students.
本文旨在利用来自学校校长和学生的问卷调查数据,研究学校建筑特征、室内环境质量(IEQ)与健康反应之间的关联。
从334所随机抽样的学校中,297所学校的4248名六年级学生参与了问卷调查。在这些学校中,134名校长返回了有关其学校51个与IEQ相关问题的问卷。广义线性混合模型(GLMM)用于研究IEQ指标与自我报告的上呼吸道症状存在之间的关联,而分层零膨胀泊松(ZIP)模型用于对症状数量进行建模。
上呼吸道症状的存在与供暖季节教室温度不理想(与适宜温度相比,过热和过冷的比值比分别为1.45,过冷的为1.27)以及2006 - 2007年期间的潮湿或湿气损坏(与无湿气损坏相比,比值比为1.80)之间分别建立了显著关联。上呼吸道症状的数量与通风不足以及潮湿或湿气损坏显著相关。通风不足的学校因呼吸道感染而缺课的天数更多(相对风险:1.16)。
本文中描述的学校层面的IEQ指标变量可以解释学生自我报告的上呼吸道症状以及因呼吸道感染而缺课天数在学校层面观察到的相对较大部分的变化。