Lortie Catherine L, Rivard Julie, Thibeault Mélanie, Tremblay Pascale
Centre de Recherche de l'Institut Universitaire en Santé Mentale de Québec, 2601 de la Canardière, Québec City, QC, Canada; Département de Réadaptation, Faculté de Médecine, Université Laval, Québec City, QC, Canada.
Nuance Communications Inc., Montréal, Canada.
J Voice. 2017 Jan;31(1):112.e1-112.e12. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2016.02.015. Epub 2016 Apr 1.
The effects of aging on voice production are well documented, including changes in loudness, pitch, and voice quality. However, one important and clinically relevant question that remains concerns the possibility that the aging of voice can be prevented or at least delayed through noninvasive methods. Indeed, discovering natural means to preserve the integrity of the human voice throughout aging could have a major impact on the quality of life of elderly adults. The objective of this study was therefore to examine the potentially positive effect of singing on voice production. To this aim, a group of 72 healthy nonsmoking adults (20-93 years old) was recruited and separated into three groups based on their singing habits. Several voice parameters were assessed (fundamental frequency [f0] mean, f0 standard deviation [SD], f0 minimum and f0 maximum, mean amplitude and amplitude SD, jitter, shimmer, and harmonic-to-noise ratio) during the sustained production of vowel /a/. Other parameters were assessed during standardized reading passage (speaking f0, speaking f0 SD). As was expected, age effects were found on most acoustic parameters with significant sex differences. Importantly, moderation analyses revealed that frequent singing moderates the effect of aging on most acoustic parameters. Specifically, in frequent singers, there was no decrease in the stability of pitch and amplitude with age, suggesting that the voice of frequent singers remains more stable in aging than the voice of non-singers, and more generally, providing empirical evidence for a positive effect of singing on voice in aging.
衰老对嗓音产生的影响已有充分记录,包括响度、音高和嗓音质量的变化。然而,一个重要且与临床相关的问题仍然存在,即嗓音衰老是否可以通过非侵入性方法预防或至少延缓。事实上,找到在整个衰老过程中保持人类嗓音完整性的自然方法,可能会对老年人的生活质量产生重大影响。因此,本研究的目的是检验唱歌对嗓音产生的潜在积极影响。为此,招募了一组72名健康的不吸烟成年人(年龄在20至93岁之间),并根据他们的唱歌习惯将其分为三组。在持续发出元音/a/的过程中,评估了几个嗓音参数(基频[f0]均值、f0标准差[SD]、f0最小值和f0最大值、平均振幅和振幅SD、抖动、闪烁以及谐波噪声比)。在标准化朗读段落期间评估了其他参数(说话f0、说话f0 SD)。正如预期的那样,在大多数声学参数上发现了年龄效应,且存在显著的性别差异。重要的是,调节分析表明,频繁唱歌可调节衰老对大多数声学参数的影响。具体而言,在频繁唱歌的人中,音高和振幅的稳定性不会随年龄增长而下降,这表明频繁唱歌者的嗓音在衰老过程中比不唱歌者的嗓音更稳定,更普遍地说,为唱歌对衰老嗓音的积极影响提供了实证证据。