Stager Sheila V, Goudelias Deanna, Johnson Aaron M
Department of Surgery, Division of Otolaryngology, The George Washington University School of Medicine, Washington, DC.
Department of Communicative Sciences and Disorders, New York University, New York, New York.
J Voice. 2023 Mar 30. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2023.02.018.
To examine the effects of short-term and long-term engagement with structured choral singing on vocal function and quality of life outcomes in older adults.
Two groups of older adult singers over 55 years, one with fewer than 4 semesters and one with 4 or more semesters singing in a chorale, were assessed at 3 time points: baseline, after 1 semester of singing, and either after 1 semester of rest or after 1 semester of rest and 1 semester more of singing. Acoustic and aerodynamic measures, voice-related quality of life ratings, and measures of singing accuracy were obtained. Percent change between time points were calculated to determine three outcomes: improvement, lack of change, or worsening of measures across time.
Long-term average spectrum (LTAS), difference in first and second harmonics and estimated subglottic pressure were significantly more likely to improve after a semester of singing with less experience singers, and LTAS continued to improve after a semester of rest. Flow was significantly more likely to improve with more singing experience after a semester of singing. Aerodynamic variables consistently changed in more experienced singers and improvement was maintained over the three visits. No significant changes occurred over time for singing accuracy for any singer type. Self-perception of singing voice continued to improve with more singing experience.
This study demonstrated that for older adults in good health, regular singing provided a mechanism for maintaining speaking voice over time.
研究短期和长期参与结构化合唱对老年人嗓音功能和生活质量的影响。
两组55岁以上的老年歌唱者,一组合唱经验少于4个学期,另一组合唱经验为4个学期或更多,在3个时间点进行评估:基线期、歌唱1个学期后、休息1个学期后或休息1个学期再歌唱1个学期后。获取声学和空气动力学指标、嗓音相关生活质量评分以及歌唱准确性指标。计算各时间点之间的百分比变化,以确定三个结果:指标随时间的改善、无变化或恶化。
经验较少的歌唱者在歌唱1个学期后,长期平均频谱(LTAS)、基频与二次谐波差值以及估计的声门下压力显著更有可能改善,且在休息1个学期后LTAS持续改善。歌唱1个学期后,经验更丰富的歌唱者气流显著更有可能改善。空气动力学变量在经验更丰富的歌唱者中持续变化,且在三次访视中改善情况得以维持。对于任何类型的歌唱者,歌唱准确性随时间均无显著变化。歌唱嗓音的自我认知随歌唱经验增加持续改善。
本研究表明,对于健康的老年人,定期歌唱为长期维持说话嗓音提供了一种机制。