van Schijndel-Speet M, Evenhuis H M, van Wijck R, van Montfort K C A G M, Echteld M A
Intellectual Disability Medicine, Department of General Practice, Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Ipse de Bruggen, Zoetermeer, The Netherlands.
J Intellect Disabil Res. 2017 Jan;61(1):16-29. doi: 10.1111/jir.12267. Epub 2016 Apr 13.
The physical activity level of older adults with intellectual disabilities (ID) is extremely low, and their fitness levels are far beneath accepted norms for older people with normal intelligence and comparable with frail older people. A physical activity programme, including an education programme, was developed for older adults with ID using behaviour change techniques. The programme aimed at improving or maintaining adequate levels of physical activity (primary outcome measure) and motor fitness, cardio respiratory fitness, morphologic and metabolic fitness, activities of daily living, cognitive functioning and depressive symptoms (secondary outcome measures).
The programme's efficacy was evaluated in a cluster-randomised clinical trial among people aged 43 years and over with mild-moderate levels of ID. Five day-activity centres were randomised to the participation group. In these centres, 81 older adults participated in groups of 8 to 10 in the programme, three times a week during 8 months. The programme was executed by physical activity instructors and staff of day-activity centres. Five other day-activity centres were randomised to the control group; 70 older adults in these centres received care as usual. The generalised linear model with mixed effects was used to test the programme's effectiveness.
Significant effects were found on physical activity, muscle strength, systolic and diastolic blood pressure, serum cholesterol level and cognitive functioning, in favour of the programme's participants. No significant improvements were found on balance, serum glucose, weight, waist circumference, walking speed, mobility, depression or instrumental activities of daily living.
The physical activity and fitness programme has established small but significant effects in this sample, but generalising the findings to other settings is difficult due to significant participant dropout. Implementation of evidence-based physical activity programmes among older adults with ID is recommended. Further research is needed to investigate the effectiveness of physical activity on daily life functioning and the development on chronic diseases in the long run.
患有智力障碍(ID)的老年人身体活动水平极低,其健康水平远低于智力正常老年人的公认标准,与体弱的老年人相当。采用行为改变技术为患有ID的老年人制定了一项包括教育计划的身体活动计划。该计划旨在改善或维持足够的身体活动水平(主要结局指标)以及运动健康、心肺健康、形态和代谢健康、日常生活活动能力、认知功能和抑郁症状(次要结局指标)。
在一项整群随机临床试验中,对年龄在43岁及以上、患有轻度至中度ID的人群评估该计划的疗效。五个日间活动中心被随机分配到参与组。在这些中心,81名老年人以8至10人一组的形式参与该计划,为期8个月,每周三次。该计划由身体活动指导员和日间活动中心的工作人员执行。另外五个日间活动中心被随机分配到对照组;这些中心的70名老年人接受常规护理。采用具有混合效应的广义线性模型来测试该计划的有效性。
在身体活动、肌肉力量、收缩压和舒张压、血清胆固醇水平和认知功能方面发现了显著效果,有利于该计划的参与者。在平衡能力、血清葡萄糖、体重、腰围、步行速度、活动能力、抑郁或日常生活工具性活动方面未发现显著改善。
该身体活动和健康计划在本样本中已产生了虽小但显著的效果,但由于参与者大量退出,难以将研究结果推广到其他环境。建议在患有ID的老年人中实施基于证据的身体活动计划。需要进一步研究以调查身体活动对日常生活功能的有效性以及从长远来看对慢性病发展的影响。