Vreeland Carol E, Alpi Kristine M, Pike Caitlin A, Whitman Elisabeth E, Kennedy-Stoskopf Suzanne
J Med Libr Assoc. 2016 Apr;104(2):100-8. doi: 10.3163/1536-5050.104.2.003.
"One Health" is an interdisciplinary approach to evaluating and managing the health and well-being of humans, animals, and the environments they share that relies on knowledge from the domains of human health, animal health, and the environmental sciences. The authors' objective was to evaluate the extent of open access (OA) to journal articles in a sample of literature from these domains. We hypothesized that OA to articles in human health or environmental journals was greater than access to animal health literature.
A One Health seminar series provided fifteen topics. One librarian translated each topic into a search strategy and searched four databases for articles from 2011 to 2012. Two independent investigators assigned each article to human health, the environment, animal health, all, other, or combined categories. Article and journal-level OA were determined. Each journal was also assigned a subject category and its indexing evaluated.
Searches retrieved 2,651 unique articles from 1,138 journals; 1,919 (72%) articles came from 406 journals that contributed more than 1 article. Seventy-seven (7%) journals dealt with all 3 One Health domains; the remaining journals represented human health 487 (43%), environment 172 (15%), animal health 141 (12%), and other/combined categories 261 (23%). The proportion of OA journals in animal health (40%) differed significantly from journals categorized as human (28%), environment (28%), and more than 1 category (29%). The proportion of OA for articles by subject categories ranged from 25%-34%; only the difference between human (34%) and environment (25%) was significant.
OA to human health literature is more comparable to animal health than hypothesized. Environmental journals had less OA than anticipated.
“同一健康”是一种跨学科方法,用于评估和管理人类、动物及其共享环境的健康与福祉,它依赖于人类健康、动物健康和环境科学领域的知识。作者的目的是评估这些领域文献样本中期刊文章的开放获取(OA)程度。我们假设人类健康或环境期刊文章的开放获取程度高于动物健康文献。
一个“同一健康”研讨会系列提供了15个主题。一名图书馆员将每个主题转化为搜索策略,并在四个数据库中搜索2011年至2012年的文章。两名独立研究人员将每篇文章归类为人的健康、环境、动物健康、所有、其他或综合类别。确定文章和期刊层面的开放获取情况。每个期刊还被分配一个主题类别并评估其索引。
搜索从1138种期刊中检索到2651篇独特文章;1919篇(72%)文章来自贡献超过1篇文章的406种期刊。77种(7%)期刊涉及所有三个“同一健康”领域;其余期刊代表人类健康487种(43%)、环境172种(15%)、动物健康141种(12%)以及其他/综合类别261种(23%)。动物健康领域开放获取期刊的比例(40%)与归类为人的健康(28%)、环境(28%)以及超过一个类别的期刊(29%)有显著差异。按主题类别划分的文章开放获取比例在25% - 34%之间;只有人类健康(34%)和环境(25%)之间的差异显著。
人类健康文献的开放获取与动物健康文献的可比性比假设的更高。环境期刊的开放获取比预期的少。