Rehm Jürgen, Larsen Elisabeth, Lewis-Laietmark Candace, Gheorghe Paul, Poznyak Vladimir, Rekve Dag, Fleischmann Alexandra
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH), Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Campbell Family Mental Health Research Institute, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2016 Jun;40(6):1283-9. doi: 10.1111/acer.13067. Epub 2016 Apr 15.
Consumption of unrecorded alcohol is prevalent, especially in low-income countries (LIC). Monitoring and reduction of unrecorded consumption have been asked for in the World Health Organization (WHO) global strategy to reduce the harmful use of alcohol. To date, only a few countries have installed monitoring systems, however.
As part of the WHO global monitoring, an expert survey using the nominal group technique, a variant of Delphi studies, was conducted to assess level and characteristics of unrecorded consumption in 46 member states. One hundred experts responded. Descriptive statistics and repeated analysis of covariance were used to analyze the data.
The study showed feasibility of the chosen methodology to elicit information of unrecorded consumption with experts responding for 74% of the countries. Response rate was lower for LIC. Compared to prior WHO estimates, experts tended to estimate higher unrecorded consumption for LIC, and lower unrecorded consumption for high-income countries. Unrecorded consumption was seen as a financial, public health, and social problem by the majority of experts. Homemade alcohol was the most prevalent subcategory of unrecorded consumption globally.
The chosen methodology was feasible, and new information about consumption of unrecorded consumption could be gathered. There is still a need for increasing efforts of national monitoring, especially in LIC.
饮用未记录在案的酒精饮料的现象很普遍,尤其是在低收入国家。世界卫生组织(WHO)减少有害使用酒精的全球战略要求对未记录在案的酒精消费进行监测和减少。然而,迄今为止,只有少数国家建立了监测系统。
作为世卫组织全球监测的一部分,采用名义群体技术(德尔菲研究的一种变体)进行了一项专家调查,以评估46个成员国未记录在案的酒精消费的水平和特征。100名专家作出了回应。使用描述性统计和重复协方差分析来分析数据。
研究表明所选方法能够获取未记录在案的酒精消费信息,74%的国家有专家作出回应。低收入国家的回应率较低。与世卫组织先前的估计相比,专家们倾向于高估低收入国家未记录在案的酒精消费量,低估高收入国家未记录在案的酒精消费量。大多数专家认为未记录在案的酒精消费是一个金融、公共卫生和社会问题。自制酒精饮料是全球未记录在案的酒精消费中最普遍的子类别。
所选方法可行,可以收集到有关未记录在案的酒精消费的新信息。仍需加大国家监测力度,尤其是在低收入国家。