Sarwar G, Peace R W, Botting H G, Brulé D
Health and Welfare Canada, Bureau of Nutritional Sciences, Ottawa, Ontario.
Plant Foods Hum Nutr. 1989;39(1):33-44. doi: 10.1007/BF01092399.
Protein efficiency ratio (PER), relative PER (RPER), net protein ratio (NPR) and relative NPR (RNPR) values, and amino acid scores were calculated for 20 food products (casein, casein + Met, beef salami, skim milk, tuna, chicken frankfuters, sausage, heated skim milk, peanut butter, rolled oats, soy isolate, chick peas, pea concentrate, kidney beans, wheat cereal, pinto bean, lentils, rice-wheat gluten cereal, macaroni-cheese, and beef stew). In most cases, PER, RPER, NPR or RNPR ranked the products in the same order and positive correlations among the protein quality methods were highly significant (r = 0.98-0.99). Amino acid scores (based on the first limiting amino acid, Lys-Met-Cys, Lys-Met-Cys-Trp or lys-Met-Cys-Trp-Thr) were positively correlated to the PER, RPER, NPR or RNPR data (r = 0.61-0.75). Inclusion of the correction for true digestibility of protein improved the correlations between amino acid scores and the indices based on rat growth. The correlations were especially high between Lys-Met-Cys scores (corrected for true digestibility of protein) and PER, RPER, NPR or RNPR (r = 0.86-0.91). Inclusion of the correction for true digestibility of individual amino acids did not result in further improvements of the correlations in most cases. It is concluded that adjusting amino acid scores for true digestibility of protein would be sufficient and further correction for digestibility of amino acids would be unnecessary in mixed diets.
计算了20种食品(酪蛋白、酪蛋白+蛋氨酸、牛肉香肠、脱脂牛奶、金枪鱼、鸡肉热狗、香肠、加热脱脂牛奶、花生酱、燕麦片、大豆分离蛋白、鹰嘴豆、豌豆浓缩物、芸豆、小麦谷物、斑豆、小扁豆、麦麸大米谷物、通心粉奶酪和炖牛肉)的蛋白质效率比(PER)、相对PER(RPER)、净蛋白比(NPR)和相对NPR(RNPR)值以及氨基酸评分。在大多数情况下,PER、RPER、NPR或RNPR对产品的排名顺序相同,蛋白质质量方法之间的正相关性非常显著(r = 0.98 - 0.99)。氨基酸评分(基于第一限制氨基酸,赖氨酸 - 蛋氨酸 - 半胱氨酸、赖氨酸 - 蛋氨酸 - 半胱氨酸 - 色氨酸或赖氨酸 - 蛋氨酸 - 半胱氨酸 - 色氨酸 - 苏氨酸)与PER、RPER、NPR或RNPR数据呈正相关(r = 0.61 - 0.75)。纳入蛋白质真消化率校正提高了氨基酸评分与基于大鼠生长的指标之间的相关性。赖氨酸 - 蛋氨酸 - 半胱氨酸评分(校正蛋白质真消化率)与PER、RPER、NPR或RNPR之间的相关性尤其高(r = 0.86 - 0.91)。在大多数情况下,纳入单个氨基酸真消化率校正并未进一步提高相关性。结论是,在混合饮食中,校正蛋白质真消化率的氨基酸评分就足够了,无需进一步校正氨基酸消化率。